Really the responses here have been great. The thing about the group on Audioholics is maybe they (we) aren't players, but that's not really the advice I'm looking for anyways. Stepping out of college, I'm more looking for a companion than just a girl to bed.
Cheers.
I think the main thing that is different for me dating now rather than in college, is that it starts off one-on-one, rather than starting in a group and then eventually being one-on-one. Always having an 'out' and other people talking, allowed for some room and space to get to know one another. I guess my anxiety is that now I have to entertain the whole night... college all I had to do was not screw it up and 'the drama' of college groups always gave something to talk about.