Yamaha RX-Z9 First Look

U

Unregistered

Guest
DD/DTS & CD through i.Link

Hi RX-Z9 Owners!
Could you tell me whether you are able to listen to DD/DTS soundtracks, as well as CD through the i.Link connection to this receiver?
If so, it will be nice to know that we can use a single i.Link cable to handle all digital audio transfer.
Thank you
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
This review is by far the most detailed ever written on a receiver. I know of no other magazine or online website that goes into this much detail. Great job!

One question about the Z9, can you engage all 9 speakers in DSP mode?
 
S

SirGromit

Audiophyte
gene said:
According to Yamaha, the Z9 limits the 480i signal of your DVD player to 480p due to copyright issues. More on this when I post my review.
My Z9 (and most of my new HT) just arrived earlier this week so I'm still learning as I go and loving every second of it. If the Z9 doesn't scale the signal from a DVD player, would it be checking the Macrovision signal or something else? If so, wouldn't this affect commercial VHS tapes as well? And if it is due to Macrovision, wouldn't it be possible to overcome this issue with some sort of box or one of those modded DVD players which strip away the Macrovision signal? Not that it matters much as I think the quality is great as it is, but it still would be neat to know. Thanks for your fantastic review!
 
Last edited:
R

Ricky

Enthusiast
Yamahaluver

EQ is a great feature recently added to modern day recievers. you have to spend a lot of time experimenting those. It is hard to believe your experience with this fine feature. In fact this is the first time I heard someone says he hates EQ. I too don't believe in the auto setup, But with EQ you can mamually adjust all the speakers in order to achieve amore balanced sound field. you might have done this before since you have years of experience with yamaha products. everyone's listening tastes are different. I just said my experience with EQ.
OK, I just returned home after listening to both the 2400 and the Z9 at the local yamaha dealer. He let me listen to both recievers in two seperate rooms both are connected to same power amps [ ROTEL 200x3 and 120x5 with B&W 9NT speakers]and here is what I felt, with movies both recievers sounded almost identical to each other though Z9 had a more detailed surround sound field. But the front sound stage is almost the same.But the story about music is different. With i-link enabled, both DVD-AUDIO and SACD sounded great on the Z9. That is the only thing we can't get from 2400 except the video upconverting feature on Z9 .So if you like movie sound you can go either way. But if you are a serious music lover you have to spend a few more bucks on the i-link. I have to say one thing at last with no harm intended YAMAHA makes very good recievers and musical instruments but not speakers. their speakers..........

cheers!!! :rolleyes:
 
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
great review

great review! not only for the product, but it was an interesting read as well :)

thanks
 
L

Leigh

Audiophyte
Z9er ( formerly canuckle ):

I have the exact same speakers up front as you do, the Paradigm studio 100 v.2 and the studio cc v.2. The rest of my speakers include the studio adp v.2, the studio 40 v.2 for rears and a pair of PSB 300's for presence as well as the servo 15 sub. Anyway I just picked up my Z9 a few days ago and I am experiencing the same thing as you did when I engage the YPAO. There is too much emphasis on the highs for my liking. Since you have had a couple of months now to play around with the settings I was wondering what you finally decided on using for watching movies? Do you use the MANUAL eq with all speakers set to flat or use the AUTO eq set to FRONT? Do you use the dsp movie modes ( sci-fi, spectacle etc.) or just straight dolby digital EX or THX Surround EX?
I'm just wondering if I should be trying something else and I figured since you have had your set-up a lot longer than I have you may have some added input. Thanks for any info you can give me!
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
DD/DTS + CD through i.Link

Could one of the RX-Z9 owners tell me whether is possible to listen to DD/DTS soundtracks and CD audio through this receiver by using its i.Link interface, please?
Thank you.
 
M

M Lo

Enthusiast
Yes, DD, DTS, PCM, and DSD come over the i.Link

JRP
Thank you!!
 
W

W4ZOO

Audioholic Intern
YPAO working better

I was having the same results as Clint with the auto setup, too bright. I have hade better luck with setting the EQ to front but the center was still bright and overbearing.

I was playing around today and installed a set of presence speakers to see how it sounded. I had an old set of B*** 101 getting dusty.

I found that the dialog lift feature became functional on all modes. The problem was it was using the presence speakers to do the lifting. My center is on the top of my RPTV. I put the center about 12" off the carpet in front of the TV.
Ran a complete set up, changed everything back to small and adjusted my sub back to 11.5 from 16'.

WOW the center sounds great !

My HT is still under construction. Currently it's a 19x14X8.5 with Double plaster walls, A little on the hard side. I have started some wall treatments but now where near what I will need. By dropping the center to the floor it is much farther from the ceiling. It has a lot more help from first reflection points on that ground.

Lots more to play with but I'm impressed with the improvement.
 
Yamahaluver

Yamahaluver

Audioholic General
Ricky said:
Yamahaluver

EQ is a great feature recently added to modern day recievers. you have to spend a lot of time experimenting those. It is hard to believe your experience with this fine feature. In fact this is the first time I heard someone says he hates EQ. I too don't believe in the auto setup, But with EQ you can mamually adjust all the speakers in order to achieve amore balanced sound field. you might have done this before since you have years of experience with yamaha products. everyone's listening tastes are different. I just said my experience with EQ.
OK, I just returned home after listening to both the 2400 and the Z9 at the local yamaha dealer. He let me listen to both recievers in two seperate rooms both are connected to same power amps [ ROTEL 200x3 and 120x5 with B&W 9NT speakers]and here is what I felt, with movies both recievers sounded almost identical to each other though Z9 had a more detailed surround sound field. But the front sound stage is almost the same.But the story about music is different. With i-link enabled, both DVD-AUDIO and SACD sounded great on the Z9. That is the only thing we can't get from 2400 except the video upconverting feature on Z9 .So if you like movie sound you can go either way. But if you are a serious music lover you have to spend a few more bucks on the i-link. I have to say one thing at last with no harm intended YAMAHA makes very good recievers and musical instruments but not speakers. their speakers..........

cheers!!! :rolleyes:
EQ is an aberration especially when a properly set up system with transparent speakers and proper room acoustic tuning can achieve the same. Already there is heavy processing going on in the studios, why add more. As for EQ, I have couple of professional level parametric EQ from ADC and Yamaha, and I have use for none. These EQs make the ones on the Yamaha receivers trivial to say the least but I have no use for either as my speakers, careful room tuning and the near-field position for the speakers take care of everything.

As per your comparison of the Yamaha receivers, using an external amp totally defeats the purpose of the comparison itself. The Z-9 has a far superior amp to the 2400 and if you bypass that and listen, the comparison is useless.

As for Yamaha speakers, it is obvious you are pretty new to the audio world. If you care to check eBay, you will see 15 to 20 year old specimens of Yamaha NS-1000 still selling for $700 upwards, its original price. This was only one of the gems from Yamaha that made it across the US shore. Speakers like NS-2000/10000 were sadly never marketed by Yamaha US and neither was their fantastic, transparent NS-200/300 or their NS-HX speakers.

Maybe all you have heard is their cheaper offerings which abound the stores across US and even then, the under $500 NS-555/777 give most speakers above their range a good run for money. Give them a thorough audition with Yamaha receivers and you will see how transparent they are.

When you do get to hear the NS-1000 mated to a Yamaha MX-1000 amp, you will see that you have no need for the EQ. Also remove the Rotel amp from the chain and let the Yamaha's amp sing, maybe you will not need the EQ then.
 
S

stick312

Audiophyte
I have 3 noob questions regarding the rx-z9. I have tried to figure the answers out short of RTFM:

1: I understand that Pure Direct (by reading Gene's review) that it does not push data thru the sub channel. I found this is true in 2 channel stereo mode as well?? is there no menu to correct this?? Sub Outs came along way before home theater, so I have no idea why it wouldn't send data to the sub out!! Is there a menu I'm missing!!!

2: When I learn other remotes. The learned unit's work fine via selecting the sources, however I am unable to bring up the rx-z9 menu anymore.. no matter how many times I hit menu (regardless of which source I'm on) It will not control the rx-z9. I also noticed that the volume on screen doesn't work sometimes (which i'm guessing is because it can't work with a high def signal)

3: My TV only has component Inputs. I would like to purchase a pioneer elite 59avi which upconverts dvd signals. If I send that signal via ilink to the yamaha (which doesn't upconvert dvd) will the yamaha pass the upconverted signal via component. (I'm guessing the answer is I need to buy a new monitor) because the rx-z9 is not designed to do dig/analog conversion..

Thanks in Advance for any help :)
 
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
hi,

1. I put a pic with this post that i found somewhere on yamaha. It's a diagram which shows how the proccessing of 2 channel audio works. Basically the sub only works in 2 channel mode if you use STRAIGHT, 2ch STEREO, or 9ch STEREO but you need to make sure the subs Bass Out is set to BOTH. In PURE DIRECT and DIRECT the Z9 bypasses alot of the proccessing including the sub out (to supposedly keep the signal "pure"), so it won't work sadly.

2.With the remote, if you take a look at it you will notice buttons with yellow/orange writting above it and the others with white writting above/on it. With the white writting buttons, you can basically do what you want with those.
The Buttons with the orange writting however, you need to be careful with as they have a dual purpose (i.e. take a look at the green DSP buttons, they can be used to act as a number pad, or to select the sound fields).
You will also note that there is a small switch next to the STEREOor1 button labled 10KEY (in green) and AMP (in orange).
When you have the switch set on AMP (in orange) and you press any button with orange writting above it it will send out the corrosponding Z9 signal. If of course you leave the switch on AMP, and learn those buttons you are overwriting the Z9 siganls.
So make sure any learning is done with the switch set on 10KEY (in green).

I don't know if this is clear so i'll give an example. The arrow buttons, you would use those to work your DVD menus, but you would also use them to navigate the Z9 GUI. So, switch to 10KEY and learn/program all your DVD buttons, up, down, left, right , enter, menu etc. (the Play, Pause, Stop etc. it doesn't matter in which mode you learn them, as they are universal). So now, with DVD selected, to navigate the menu or type in a chapter number, flick the switch to 10KEY and your away, to then change the sound field, or to navigate the GUI just flick it back over to AMP.

3. wouldn't have a clue, sorry

hope i help a bit :)
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:
S

stick312

Audiophyte
Thanks KrazyKaj,
I just played with the menus and I'm still a little confuzed LOL
1: the only option I found where it says BOTH (refers to sending signal to BOTH my sub AND my sub) when I select it I believe that's what it does is send lower frequencies to my mains. When I click on stereo then have the 3 options Direct/PCM/ 9 Channel/2Channel 9 it only gives me level options. Guess I'll have to keep playing with it :)

2: so in short, you're saying when I program the non-green keys make sure it's not set to amp or I'll program OVER the amp keys. I thought the amp switch only effected the green keys and the others would work depending on which unit I had selected LOL. I think I would rather have it setup my way Oh well.

3: I'm still betting money I need to pickup a newtv with HDMI/DVI to upconvert from a 59avi... I was just hoping if I passed the RX an upconverted signal it would just pass that signal via component.. :p

Thanks Again!! you're post helped me quite a bit with my programming confusion :D
 
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
hello again

1. i'm guessing this is the case. but with the Bass Out option in your Subwoofer Set menu you should have the option of BOTH, SWFR and FRONT. Refer to the maual for a bit more detail: but (this is assuming your front speakers are set to LARGE and you crossover is, say, set at 80Hz) when you set the setting to BOTH it means it will send the full range of sound to you Fronts as well as the frequencies below 80Hz going to your Fronts to the Sub.
This means however, when playing a 5.1 audio track with a dedicated sub or LFE channel the Subwoofer is getting the dedicated sound PLUS the Sound going to your Fronts cut off at 80Hz (or whatever specified). This of course increases the output levels and actual sound output of your sub so you may set it up perfectly for 2ch STEREO, but then when you play a DTS movie the Sub might seem a bit loud or Woofy as it's getting extra singals. You'll need to play around with the settings to get an "inbetween" level so both music and Movies sound good in the bass.
Or you could switch the Sub settings to BOTH when playing Stereo Music, and then when you go to watch a movie, switch the setting to SWFR (this means only dedicated LFE signals will be sent to the sub, which is why when you have this setting in stereo music no sound will play out of the sub as there is no info for the sub to play). but this switching between the two is a bit tedious

I have my setting on BOTH all the time and i have it set up to what i would call "near perfect" so just see what you like and set you level accordingly.

2. You can program any key on the remote just keep in mide most have two uses, the first is what you want that key to do, the second is preprogramed to control features on the Z9. And all that switch does is switches between the two "virtual" remotes.

3. the best way is to get the equipment you wanted and try it (just get it from somwhere that does a return policy), theoredically it should work. but again, i am no authority in this area.

cheers
 
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
oh yeah,

1: the only option I found where it says BOTH (refers to sending signal to BOTH my sub AND my sub) when I select it I believe that's what it does is send lower frequencies to my mains. When I click on stereo then have the 3 options Direct/PCM/ 9 Channel/2Channel 9 it only gives me level options. Guess I'll have to keep playing with it​

i didn;t quite get what you were saying here. The only options you need to change are in the MANUAL SETUP - BASIC - SUBWOOFER SET - BASS OUT. That's all i am refering too, i may have missunderstood you otherwise.
And the only other option you need to check it in MANUAL SETUP - BASIC - SPEAKER SET - FRONT, make sure it's Large

then you just press the Straight Button on your Remote down the bottom, or select 2ch Stereo by repetedly pressing the STEREO button on the remote untill it displays and you should have the subwoofer playing away.

Note: i am in Australia, though i think the units should be the same if you are elsewhere
 
S

stick312

Audiophyte
THANKS That did it!!! I was worried about sending the data to both but I switched the crossover from 200 to 80... (hahah like i know what I'm doing) Anyway, it sounds great!!! Thanks Again for your help :) :D
 
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
Yamaha, it's unacceptable

No probs,

Now my problem i am having . . . and sadly i personally think it reflects very badly on Yamaha!

Hi,

I bought the Z9 nearly three months ago and i have been having great problems with it and MORE SO, with Yamaha. You may find it interesting. (i also posted at Audioholics and possible elswhere to)

Firstly i want to say the Z9 sound GREAT, my issue is not with that. It's the Video processing that's causing major problems!!!

It's been nearly three months now and in that time Yamaha have had to send out THREE units.

We bought the Z9 partly for the Faroudja DCDi processing as it caught our eye from Yamaha's BIG advertising about this feature and other peoples positive views.

The first Unit we got was a dud it terms of video, it didn't even pass the signal through, not Component GUI, nothing. I think that unit was a Pre release on or something like that (who knows, maybe just faulty). We took it to where we bought it (they were a good help), confirmed it there and they sent for a new one for us.

About a week or two later! We finally hear something about a new one coming for us. It eventually arrives. This one seems ok on first appearances, the Component output worker, the GUI was displayed via it, the Processor would turn on and video was displayed. BUT. on closer inspection we saw that what was being outputted was completely unacceptable. Colour bleeding, artefacts, skewed top 20 or so lines, serious flickering etc.
Without going into major detail we tried everything, three different DVD players, and many DVD's (seeing as that's all were concerned with at the momvent, DVD
s, nothing else). We contacted Yamaha Immediately with the help of the purchase store. It took about a week to get ANY reply and all we got then was told that it is our problem, something to do with our TV and sync problems. This was of course to us outrageous (again, i won't write an essay, but we eliminated that it was our TV as i will show further on), eventually again, about a week and a half later of us constantly contacting them trying to get something done we get told that Yamaha have released a Firmware update that will fix all our Problems and that they will send someone to install it.

Well, this was a complete joke in itself! The guy came (very nice bloke), and the first thing he told us was that he'd never done this sort of thing before, and that he had just joined Yamaha and been with them for four weeks!!!!!!!! already the alarm bells were ringing. It got worse, the guy, no offence to him, didn't seem to know how to use a computer, he was on the phone non-stop to a techi in another state asking and getting instructions on how to Un-zip a file!!!! eventually i couldn't stand it and offered my help here and there.
Three hours later (it was meant to take half an hour) even he gave up because he couldn't get the third update to work (there were three separate files to upload). So, ok, we turned on the Z9, put in a DVD and sure enough, as we told Yamaha a week earlier, it didn't Work, in fact it seemed a bit worse to Yamaha's embaressment, the guy saw for himself.

He went away and promised to contact us the following day. Nothing, we had to ring them, and then Two days later we hear something. They tell us it is our TV and it's not being able to handle the signal and we’d have to live with it. If i went through the details, you'd see how 'illogical' this was. So we sent a rather long email to them, completely showing our case and showing that we're not that silly (available to all if wanted). But not only that, other things they were telling us, supposedly explaining the problem was just plain WRONG, contradicted by reviews, Faroudja (like upconverting ALL interlaced signals to 720p regadless of copyright) etc. (Update, they've now correctlyt old us this isn't the case). Yet no matter how much we showed them (from our point of view that it was the Z9 they always were telling us it wasn't. So finally we said we'd take it to the Store, us the equipment and staff there and test it.

So unplugging the z9 (NOT FUN), lugging it around for the fiftieth time (NOT FUN) we set it up at the store and sure enough, the problem came right along with the Z9! It wasn’t our TV as we said. So the store, who had been Extremely helpful over this time, they even contacted Yamaha.

We didn't hear much from anyone after that (just the store, to our appreciation) only got info a few days later that a new Z9 was shipping.

We get the THIRD Z9 a few days ago. This one we didn't bother taking home, we set it up in the store, with a Denon 2200 DVD player (the one we have at home) and a high end Fujitsu Plasma screen. I think it may have worked for about five minutes, then DIED, back to the same problems as we've had for three months!!! or maybe we were so bent on getting a working one we fooled ourselves :)

Is this normal. This is Yamaha's FLAGSHIP model, and we still haven't got a fully working unit to date as far as we're concerned. Not only that we and the store have had to spend ridicules amounts of time, effort, money and lots of panadols trying to fix this problem because it’s the worst support i've had!

ok, fair enough for their cheap $100 model, but this thing cost $10 000! and for that, over a time span of three months we get told basically it's our problem.
I SHOULD NOT have to prove i am right like I did
I SHOULD NOT have to argue with Yamaha
I SHOULD NOT have to waste my time and money to fix something that Yamaha should, or at least each and correct and Show me!
What happened to the Customer is always right!
I was wondering if anyone else has had problems, and if this is what i am expect from Yamaha (though it’s not like they are a small company and comprised of armatures and they do have a fairly good reputation, even with us originally), and is there anyway or anything i can do to get them to do something and not take three months to do it.

I think I shall also contact the Board of Fair Trading, and see what they say about all this.

If there is any help you guys could give, or any suggestions, I would be most appreciative. There are obviously working Z9’s out there, as the recent Review and other happy buyers have confirmed, all I ask Yamaha is that I get one of those or that the problem be shown, and then corrected in a quick and friendly manner, not a pile of rubbish in the Product and in the Service.

Thanks
If there are any details you need I am most happy to give them. Who know maybe it is our problem (though in my mind, i'm convinced otherwise) but in anycase Yamaha should be helping, not hindering! No?
 
Last edited:
K

Krazykaj

Junior Audioholic
sorry, i forgot to add this

my equipment:

Denon DVD-2200
Tara Labs Interconects
LG MW-60SZ12 LCD Projection Monitor
Yamaha RX-Z9 (still of course faulty)

i have also used the following equipement (i don't know exact details, sorry):
Sony Trinitor Wega TV
Fujitsu Plasma screen
2 toshiba buget DVD players
Phillips DVD player
Panasonic DVD player (RP-82 i think???)

normally i wouldn't be making such a hoo-haa, i've had faulty products before, i understand it happens (though not three in a row), but i have never had this type of response as i have had from Yamaha
 
Last edited:
R

Ricky

Enthusiast
Yamahaluver said:
EQ is an aberration especially when a properly set up system with transparent speakers and proper room acoustic tuning can achieve the same....

Yamahaluver
I am a Japanese natoinal staying in Taiwan due to my working contract with the pioneer cooperatin Taiwan branch. I am going back to Japan on my vacation.I will write about how famous yamaha speakers and power amps here in ASIA and Japan when I get back next week.
As for the EQ , depending on your personal listening taste EQ might not suitable for your system. But many audio enthusiasts out there like me welcome this fine feature with open hands. Anyway thank you for your opinions.
THANKS!!!

[Edit: Fixed quote code - HawKe]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top