Okay so I had those settings hooked up. I have a suspicion the subwoofer wiring is loose. I will take it apart tonight and bypass the terminal post. See if that gives me different results. I would guess, even if the signals are not matching up perfectly from Audioengine A5's to amp I should still be able to get the subwoofer to move at least a little bit? Next on the list is ruling out the amp.
How do I do this?
I can pick up my EQ later this week from the FedEx location. I also have all my proper wiring coming today/tomorrow. I understand this should rule out any signal issues from PC to Subwoofer? The other Chris mentioned I might need to get a Samson S-Convert worst case. Under these assumptions, I think I can rule out a ton of problems and if it turns out to be a faulty amp I will need to grab another.