Yep - I told him that I could live with the scratch, but not with the defective operation. The scratch is part of the story, though. He sold it as 9/10 on Audiogon - that means no scratches...none. This thing was cosmetically 8/10. He claimed that he took extra care in packing it to prevent any damage during shipping. Hence, either it was scratched before it was packed, or he didn't actually pack it well. I made it clear that the packing looks to be in fine shape and that there was no visible damage to the plastic wrap around the amp.
Yeah, like that's not going to get quoted in another thread.
That said - agreed.