I think it highly ironic that the lesson about walls is lost on us today. I remember the Berlin wall. Anybody else? And what it meant and represented?
Oppression and division.
@killdozzer, Perhaps you have some insight about the former Eastern Bloc countries, their strongman Dictators, and life in them?
@herbu, what does it matter if views change? Even if somebody wanted a wall 5 years ago and doesn't now? Whether it is political motivation or an actual change in thought (dare I call it enlightenment?... no.
) that drives it? (That is not morality, though.)
(Mind,
@herbu, I did try to look at the philosophical aspect of your question in several posts already, without directly getting political.
Your question, at face value, is important and valid: the politics is a red herring.)
On the other hand, the clear nationalistic, isolationist, exclusionist, racist, fear-mongered rhetoric in support of building
this wall
IS immoral. Of that, there is and can be no doubt.
The Soviet backed government of East Germany killed many people trying to cross to the West, yet people still succeeded. How would
this wall be any different? In symbology? In practice? In protecting life?
The only life of interest being protected is that of the dying white-male-majority leadership class.
I am neither Democrat nor Republican. I am not interested in politics any longer, beyond what is of the greatest good for the citizenry of the United States. I was raised in a conservative, Midwest household. I have no ill-memories of my childhood while growing up under Reagan. But as I pointed out before, Reagan could not be a Republican in today's GOP.
The modern republican party is a duplicitous tool of the wealthy which uses the evangelical population as a
White-velvet coozy to support and shore up its base.
The single greatest threat to our democratic republic is the voter apathy which is oft lamented and well documented for any that care to look. It is OUR responsibility to guide our elected leaders, not just rubber stamp their ascendancy to the leadership class of McConnell, Schumer, Pelosi, Cheney, Bush, Clinton... or any other. Voter turnout in most elections is abysmal because they aren't glorious. But those School Board members, local Sheriffs, city council/assembly people, state assembly... This is where the future of our country starts. We turn our backs on these contests, and we lose the single greatest part of our process: Choosing Our Leaders.
I'm done now.
and