Going Dual, add another sealed or replace with dual ported subs?

[lovinthehd]

I do not believe Amir would test a subwoofer. They require outside ground plane measurements for CEA-2010 comparison numbers. But, as per above, Erin does them. BTW, the last reviewer to review a PSA subwoofer was Shane Lee. While the overall review was positive he did mention just one problem, and for that, he was thoroughly criticized by zealous owners.

He will but doubt many are sending one to him otoh https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/rythmik-l12-subwoofer-review.12140/

 

[Golfx]

If it wasn't so expensive to ship them (sounds like a few hundred each way) I'd offer mine to be measured by ASR. Not sure how well Amir is received here but I do appreciate the objective measurements!

Forgot to mention from looking at your room I have decided you do not have toddler children or grandchildren.

 

[-Jim-]

I checked last night and as far as I can tell Amir has only reviewed 5 Subs total.

 

[Golfx]

I checked last night and as far as I can tell Amir has only reviewed 5 Subs total.

Like James says the CEA 2010 numbers really have to be from the same reviewer/method style to get an accurate comparison. Amir uses his Klippel not ground plane—so even more reason to send to audioholics.

 

[justex07]

Forgot to mention from looking at your room I have decided you do not have toddler children or grandchildren.

Haha nope. Just two dudes with two cats and a bunch of (outdoor) chickens.

 

[justex07]

Like James says the CEA 2010 numbers really have to be from the same reviewer/method style to get an accurate comparison. Amir uses his Klippel not ground plane—so even more reason to send to audioholics.

I’ll be sure to keep my boxes in case that comes up, assuming they pay the shipping haha.

I also wanted to close the loop here. Thanks everyone for your help. I chose the dual PSA EV18F-M path and made my order last night after several emails with Tim and great feedback here.

I can’t wait to get the shipping confirmation so I can start my countdown! I’ll be sure to share first impressions once they arrive.

Thanks again.

 

[William Lemmerhirt]

Sweeeeeeeeeeeet!!!!!!!!!!

 

[justex07]

Like James says the CEA 2010 numbers really have to be from the same reviewer/method style to get an accurate comparison. Amir uses his Klippel not ground plane—so even more reason to send to audioholics.

I emailed Audioholics after your post but never heard back. Just fwiw.

 

[-Jim-]

I emailed Audioholics after your post but never heard back. Just fwiw.

Just ask @shadyJ

 

[justex07]

Thanks everyone! The beasts have arrived! Dual PSA EV18F-M subs plus four RSL C34E MKII for Dolby Atmos heights.

To install the RSL ceiling speakers we’re gonna have to climb through the attic and run wires. I welcome any tips for installing speakers like these.

But the two PSA EV18F-M subs were put into place yesterday. After calibration with ARC Genesis we’ve got them tuned into the room and holy crap. This is bass like I’ve only ever experienced at a nice theater.

The fact that the gain is at around 20% in our room, good lord what would happen if I turned that up?! The most impressive part to me is how great they sound with music, even at low volumes. Just effortless and graceful bass. It do eat stick out but boy does it hit low!

Comparing both or even one to the previous sub for this room, an SVS SB 13 Ultra is so unfair. The price to performance ratio here is out of this world.

Attached is a photo of one of them with the SVS on top. Isn’t it cute with its entire cabinet about the width of the PSA driver?

 

[justex07]

Congrats, they are pretty awesome! Mess around with the room size compensation until you find the sweet spot. I ended up between 1/2 and 3/4.

I can't imagine how heavy those are with the ferrite driver. I had the B&C and it's around 25lbs lighter I believe.

I wish there was an illustration that showed how the room size adjustments worked. Has that been well documented/explained anywhere? I think both are set to around the same as you. I’ll continue to tweak!

Yes, the ferrite drivers are heavy! But at 125 lbs each, I was able to easily place them in the room, though carrying them into the house required a helping hand.

I was so tempted to go with the B&C drivers but Tom kind of talked me out of it. Similar to same performance for less money but heavier. The weight isn’t an issue for me and the money saved was enough to add the 4 RSL speaker for heights so I consider it a fair trade off.

 

[William Lemmerhirt]

I wish there was an illustration that showed how the room size adjustments worked. Has that been well documented/explained anywhere? I think both are set to around the same as you. I’ll continue to tweak!

Yes, the ferrite drivers are heavy! But at 125 lbs each, I was able to easily place them in the room, though carrying them into the house required a helping hand.

I was so tempted to go with the B&C drivers but Tom kind of talked me out of it. Similar to same performance for less money but heavier. The weight isn’t an issue for me and the money saved was enough to add the 4 RSL speaker for heights so I consider it a fair trade off.

So I could find a couple things on a quick search. Here’s what the graph looks like.

Here’s Tom’s answer to someone. Hope this sorts it out.

 

[justex07]

So I could find a couple things on a quick search. Here’s what the graph looks like.

Here’s Tom’s answer to someone. Hope this sorts it out.

This is awesome. Thanks!