Thanks, man. I was told this morning that they need to redispute it (so, I'm assuming reopen the case like you said). I did get a response to my message already this morning after I uploaded the new proof, but it was from someone new saying that they'll send it to the department that I'm assuming that I'd already been working with. I think the only real screw up of this whole thing was not returning it right away. I told them that I hadn't returned it when I opened the dispute and that I was waiting for them to tell me if I should. After all, I didn't want to return it and them have them tell me that I still had to pay. I never heard from them. I admit that I was disappointed when I contacted them a month later (after the seller asked for the amp back because he thought that I got my refund), and they said that they couldn't continue the investigation because there wasn't any proof that it had been returned. Ummm, no kidding - I told them that I hadn't returned it and was waiting to hear from them. Then, to have them close the dispute and add back in the charges after they instructed me to return it, I did return it, and I uploaded proof that I had returned it like they asked - now that bothered me. I know it's probably just a ramification of a large company and things falling through the automated cracks, but it still bothers me. Because now I'm in the boat that I was trying to avoid in the first place - I returned it and they're still charging me the money.
I should call. I know. I'm just not that awesome on the phone when it comes to stuff like this.
edit: feel free to pm me and we can discuss this more. Customer service is a passion of mine. One pf the perks is knowing how to make things work to your advantage. Best advice I can give to anyone is be clear, concise, and polite. That will get you places.
Edit: as a matter of fact, fell free to pm me and I'll give you my tn if you want even more in depth advice. Customer service is a passion of mine, a perk of that is I know how to best work the system in a case like this. it's all about being clear, concise and polite about your problem and the resolution you'd like to see. Merry xmas and best of luck
On a more serious note - really, no one falls for the pants down/mistletoe thing? Huh. I thought with it being the holidays and all, and I'm standing on a Twister mat...