I loved this movie. I'm not a hardcore trekkie, but I've pretty much watched all of them (except for the original series). I grew up watching the original movies (and purchased the Blu-ray set when they released it), then when NG came out I watched all of them (and have purchased the NG Blu-Ray set as well), I watched all of Deep Space 9, most of Voyager, and only a couple episodes of the series that was showing a young kirk just starting out. I enjoy them all, but I don't go to conventions or have any federation uniforms.
I really enjoyed what they did with the story and have pretty much set it up to do anything they want (even do stuff over but differently due to the altered reality). I watched the Blu-ray last night and just got immursed in the audio and the beauty of the video. I was also happy to read that the major cast members have signed on for at least 2 sequals and it appears that JJ Abrams and the same writers will be part of them as well. I'm excited to see where they take it.