If it's all about stats on the field, then tell me why Ken Stabler isn't in the HOF?
I won't dispute that TO is a good receiver, but the guy's a moron. He's been a Cancer and a distraction at EVERY city he's been in. I don't care how good he is, his attitude and lack of team mentality make me hate him.
Stabler is a terrible comparison. He only had 4 years that could be considered good/great, and for his career he threw 30 more INTs than TDs. I would agree that he's a borderline guy, but that's nowhere near what TO is.
To put Mazer's stats in perspective:
-TO is #6 on the list in all time receptions (Assuming he plays 3-4 more years at average production he'll retire at #2)
-He's #5 in all time receiving yardage (unless Isaac Bruce or Marvin Harrison have resurgences, he's almost guaranteed to finish his career at #2)
- #2 in all time receiving TDs (nobody is catching Jerry Rice, but Randy Moss will end up passing TO within a year of his retirement)
He also averages 75 yards per game (9th best all time) and according to Pro Football Reference, the list of players to whom his career is most comparable include Steve Largent, Marvin Harrison, Raymond Berry, and Tim Brown.
He also may be a jerk, but since when did you have to be a nice guy to be considered one of the best ever at your position??
The defining TO moment for me was his performance in the Super Bowl with Philly after destroying his leg towards the regular season. The doctors said there's no way he'd play in the game, yet he still comes out and catches 9 balls for almost 140 yards.
P.S. I hate the guy too, but I respect his ability on the field, which is the only thing that matters.