Which set would perform better?

[GilbertHaul]

What's up guys,

I got a simple question here, which set would stand out of all three:

1) Logitech X-530

Total FTC power: 70 watts RMS
Satellites:
Left/right: 7.4 watts RMS x 2 (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Center: 15.5 watts RMS (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Rear left/right: 7.4 watts RMS x 2 (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Subwoofer: 25 watts RMS (into 4 ohms, @ 100 Hz, @ 10% THD)
# Total peak power: 140 watts 
Frequency response: 40 Hz–20 kHz 
# Signal-to-noise ratio: >96 dB

2) Creative SBS A500

Satellite Speaker Power: 	6 Watts RMS per channel(5 channels)
Subwoofer Power: 	17 Watts RMS
Frequency Response 	45Hz ~ 20kHz
Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR): 	75dB

3) Creative LX-520

Specifications:
-Satellite Speaker Power : 6 Watts RMS per channel (5 channels)
-Subwoofer Power : 16 Watts RMS
-Frequency Response : 40Hz ~ 20kHz
-Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) : 75dB

I know that all three sets are average according to most of the standards around here , but I'd like to know which one would be best.

Many thanks in advance!

P.S: Sorry for not posting links to the speakers, it's because I couldn't do that until I have a total of 5 posts and I'm not going to just spam the forum to increase it.

Cheers,

 

[BoB/335]

What's up guys,

I got a simple question here, which set would stand out of all three:

1) Logitech X-530

Total FTC power: 70 watts RMS
Satellites:
Left/right: 7.4 watts RMS x 2 (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Center: 15.5 watts RMS (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Rear left/right: 7.4 watts RMS x 2 (into 4 ohms, @ 1 kHz, @ 10% THD)
Subwoofer: 25 watts RMS (into 4 ohms, @ 100 Hz, @ 10% THD)
# Total peak power: 140 watts 
Frequency response: 40 Hz–20 kHz 
# Signal-to-noise ratio: >96 dB

2) Creative SBS A500

Satellite Speaker Power: 	6 Watts RMS per channel(5 channels)
Subwoofer Power: 	17 Watts RMS
Frequency Response 	45Hz ~ 20kHz
Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR): 	75dB

3) Creative LX-520

Specifications:
-Satellite Speaker Power : 6 Watts RMS per channel (5 channels)
-Subwoofer Power : 16 Watts RMS
-Frequency Response : 40Hz ~ 20kHz
-Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) : 75dB

I know that all three sets are average according to most of the standards around here , but I'd like to know which one would be best.

Many thanks in advance!

P.S: Sorry for not posting links to the speakers, it's because I couldn't do that until I have a total of 5 posts and I'm not going to just spam the forum to increase it.

Cheers,

6 watts per channel and 16 watts for a sub? Stock stereos in cars 30 years ago were 5 watts per channel. I think a stock stereo in even a cheap car is 15-20 watts I think. If your question is serious I can't answer it at all.

 

[GilbertHaul]

@BoB, they're computer speakers, I suppose that's the reason ?

 

[BoB/335]

@BoB, they're computer speakers, I suppose that's the reason ?

Duh!!! Logitech and Creative should have been dead give-aways. My bad.

 

[just-some-guy]

look at TSC The Speaker Company, they advertise here. they have some nice computer speakers, at what looks like a good price. i'm thinking about buying a set, and i don't even need em.

 

[lsiberian]

I wouldn't buy creative anything. I have had just too many issues with their products. If you give us a budget we might be able to suggest a nice stereo system that would exceed the quality of the computer speaker.

That's just a thought.

Logitech makes decent stuff, but I think Klipsch makes computer speakers. I would prefer a speaker company over a company that makes everything.