Please let us know how it is. If it's good I will wait and buy it on physical for the much better experience. I'm not going to bother with streaming anymore for the good action movies at least until their HDR\/DV and Atmos\/DTS-X match or best physical.\n\nI'd have to say it was okay. Not terrible, but not great.\n\nIt's been many years since I read the novel, but the movie plot seemed to be only loosely based on the novel. To me, it seemed unrealistic, but my wife said she liked it because it was more realistic than a lot of the Sci Fi movies I watch. \n\nTo me, the movie tries to do too much with the John Kelly character. The character seemed to be designed by a committee in an effort to have a little something that would appeal to everyone. It was as if he was too perfect, but in contradictory ways (both perfectly good in some ways and perfectly bad in others, but without any real inner conflict).\n\nI imagine some of this has to do with expectations. I loved the novel, but this may have created unrealistically high expectations for the movie.\n\nDisclaimer: I'm sure my taste in movies is different than most. For example, Terminator Salvation was probably my favorite Terminator movie, but I'm probably the only person on the planet who feels that way.