Ok, after a little research I think it comes down to the...
onkyo tx-sr605, 607, or 608
...or the
Yamaha RX-V663
Both are slightly over $200, although I think I can get a new/refirb Onkyo 605 from Amazon for about $230. Emig5M, let me know where you stand as I'd be interested in the V663 from a forum member for $200. Do you have the original box, cables, etc?
Otherwise, the Onkyo 600 series have received awesome reviews online, so I'd be leaning in that direction.