Reviewing Home Theater Related Product Reviews

S

Schrodinger23

Audioholic Intern
@gene

"Yet, other than for Audioholics, where are the e-zine reviews that cover a product in such detail?"

I know of a precious few, but not many.


Thanks for being one of the few true sources of audio reviews! Your review of the HK3490 was the main decision that led me to buy it when I spotted it on a closeout special a few years ago. I've really enjoyed it.
Here are three sources for displays that I find very good:

https://www.rtings.com/ is excellent for flat panel comparisons. Very detailed.
https://www.projectorreviews.com/ is excellent for projector reviews. Very detailed.
https://www.cnet.com/products/lg-oled55b6p/review/ CNET's David Katzmaier does an excellent job with displays.
 
JohnBooty

JohnBooty

Enthusiast
I'd just take what Ken R says with a grain of salt given his shameless affiliate link galore on every single page where are few dozen aff. links. But two other solid sources and I'm avid reader of both.
Agreed. I always tread verrrrry carefully when affiliate links are a major part of the equation. I think he's done some really good work in the audio domain though, particularly his measurements of the audio performance of Apple devices. Not all of his audio reviews are valuable; his speaker and headphone reviews are pretty much just his subjective opinions.

Ironically (given the main focus of his site) I stopped reading his photography recommendations many years ago because I felt his photography essays had become almost troll-like.

Here are three sources for displays that I find very good:

https://www.rtings.com/ is excellent for flat panel comparisons. Very detailed.
https://www.projectorreviews.com/ is excellent for projector reviews. Very detailed.
https://www.cnet.com/products/lg-oled55b6p/review/ CNET's David Katzmaier does an excellent job with displays.
Thank you for listing those!
 
Gerry Nason

Gerry Nason

Audiophyte
This just makes me appreciate the value of user reviews available right here on Audioholics. I've already given up on the fake "user comments" that are stocked on the product pages by the manufacturers and/or distributors of products. It is rather unfair and unscrupulous to publish fake reviews to sway potential buyers. The internet can be a really great thing, but more and more you must be aware of malignant content being pushed upon us. So a hearty "Thank You" goes out to Audioholics and its readers!
 
C

Charles H

Audiophyte
Regarding the article on fake reviews, I agree on some of the websites reviewing components. I'm partial to Cnet reviews, since they take their own pictures of the component in review, and give their own pros and cons regarding the said component too. It's sometimes not practical to measure all the spec's given by the manufacturer, so they do their best with what they have. They give a reasonable in depth review of all the the features and how it performs in real life situations. I trust their opinions. It's true that get compensated if you click on a company selling that product, but at least they tell you that before hand, so you can judge for your self whether or not to believe what they review. You can't always say that for other review websites, since as said in your article they could be just rehashing press releases and really reviewing it themselves. You can take what I've said with a grain of salt. This is my two cents worth. The product that they reviewed and I purchased was exactly as they recommended, and performed to my expections. I was well pleased with my choice from their review.
 
K

Kenco278

Enthusiast
I would add to the list a great site of long standing, with a quirky interface that ultimately works well after a little getting used to. Heavy on text and photos, with an extensive collection of music and audio reviews. It has numerous small uniformly formatted ads grouped tastefully together often for interesting products you've never heard of - I usually ignore ads but these pique my interest. Hundreds of archived reviews of audio equipment and music dating back to 2002.

http://www.6moons.com
 
nicknotice

nicknotice

Audiophyte
I have noticed this and have been wondering what the heck is going on. These "reviews" as they are called don't seem to say anything useful, yet provide a million product links to mostly made in China goods that can be found anywhere. The strategy of looking for original imagery is really good, though I'm not sure what's to prevent one of these "reviews" from simply stealing other more natural imagery.

In the end, I suppose most people don't care about sound quality, as long as they can find something that looks cool and doesn't cost much.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sean M Mouradian

Sean M Mouradian

Audiophyte
Great article, but you realize you're giving these guys backlinks, right? That's how I found this article...
 
gene

gene

Audioholics Master Chief
Administrator
Great article, but you realize you're giving these guys backlinks, right? That's how I found this article...
Uggh I know. It's something we need more of but I felt it was important to discuss this topic.
 
Pogre

Pogre

Audioholic Slumlord
The first one looks like it was written by a fifth grader...
 
X

x4393

Audiophyte
I've run into those types of sites with multiple different types of products when I was searching for reviews. Those sites are absolutely useless.

If Google weren't so big and in control of most things online it would be laughed at for things like this. Instead it just becomes less and less useful over time and people accept that.

The internet is over 90% crap as it is and Google continues to encourage more useless content with boosting these sites rather than blocking them altogether.

These sites are worse than the old link farms because these try to appear like they are giving advice; and we have to wade through page after page of them to find actually useful sites like this one.
And we end up with living brain donors thinking "My new amp was on the top 5 list at bestampstobuy.com!"
 
Last edited:
X

x4393

Audiophyte
I would add to the list a great site of long standing, with a quirky interface that ultimately works well after a little getting used to. Heavy on text and photos, with an extensive collection of music and audio reviews. It has numerous small uniformly formatted ads grouped tastefully together often for interesting products you've never heard of - I usually ignore ads but these pique my interest. Hundreds of archived reviews of audio equipment and music dating back to 2002.

http://www.6moons.com
While I appreciate the work they do; I have trouble getting past the 75% ads 25% content. It is great for killing time with ADD because there is a lot to see but when I just want to read about a specific product it is like a 'where's waldo' book for finding the review text among the advertisements.
 
K

Kenco278

Enthusiast
On the subject of Google, you can avoid its apparently biased search results and also avoid search engine tracking by using DuckDuckGo as your standard search engine.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top