When I play an LP, 99% of the time, it's all the way through (unless I'm at TLSGuy's place, then it's selected tracks), so I record them that way. I used to go one side, one file. Now, it's one LP - one file. So it's fine not necessarily using itunes. I'd have to use some kind of player like itunes if I had individual tracks as files.
Btw, that thing melted. In seconds, there is no doubt it would have been smoking. Thank God, I avoided a potential disaster. I do have two fire extinguishers in the house. I hope I never need them!