Wasn't brought up on this site but another one apparantly. Ask Shinerman. Apparantly he got the rattle and sent the sub in for repairs, got a new sub replacement that had the flaw and waited around a year to report it.
As for the sub being under warranty it is not a no fault warranty so there is no 100% for sure promise to service. Is your logic I spent more money so I deserve to get service other customers won't? I feel Paradigm has a right to be suspicious of this claim. That doesn't mean that they are correct, only justified in refusing replacement in this instance. To a manufacturer it could simply sound like buyers remorse and a desire to upgrade.
If you guys expect your equipments manufacturer to replace what looks like watersatined epuipment a year after you receive it and claim that you "Just can't live with it anymore but it's been there all along honest", then you might be dissapointed. This is not a slam against you Brianphoto but the last time I checked you can buy furniture touch up pens to match rosewood and that could explain why the damage area looks painted after damage. Also they probably put about 5 or so coats of stain on that speaker, more than enough to let it soak in to the depth where minor nicks would still be showing the same colour. Lord knows I am lazy enough to be in the same boat you are in. But seriously, when did you take the grill off? Was it ever aside from taking photos to post?
I'm not doubting your claim Brianphoto, just stating why I don't feel this is the manufacturer's responsibility. I agree your dealer should have done more for you. Even if he didn't believe you, you had shown him that you were willing to spend large amounts of money to be happy with your purchase. I would want you and all of your friends as customers, the easy way to do this is to accomodate you. He should have worked extra hard to please you, instead I wonder how happy you are with his service and will he get your business again?