Please help me pick a projector!

[cthomp]

After reading a lot of reviews, I think I have the choice narrowed down to three projectors. This is based on spending under $3000.

Panasonic PT-AE900U
Sanyo PLV-Z4
Sony VPL-HS51A

The problem is we don't have any showrooms here in Fairbanks,Ak
so I would like to get other users comments on which would be the
better projector! Room is 17'W x 25'L x 8"H. Seating would be at about
15-20ft. Good light control. I have seen the Sony HS51 (not A) in action
on a trip to Spokane, It was beautiful! Any help would be appreciated!
The screen that I like is the 106" Carada Criterion w/brilliant white
Thanks

 

[BMXTRIX]

I personally would not go for the Sony - I just think that their pricing vs. technology is a bit high and behind what Panny and Sanyo are offerring. But, between the Panny and Sanyo you have a very - VERY - tough choice.

At that viewing distance, I would probably go with the Z4 just for the sharper overall image. But, it really requires a good source like HDTV or a well upconverted DVD. Perhaps pick up a Panny S77 DVD player to go with it.

The AE900i is no slouch either though and some consider it a better projector. It really is different things that make both projectors great and neither holds an obvious advantage. I know that I prefer a sharper image over the smooth screen technology that the AE900 delivers. But, I have seen the AE900 and still wouldn't be bummed to have it in my home.

Of course there's always the Epson 550.

Make sure to check www.projectorcentral.com and do some reading if you haven't yet.

 

[wilkenboy]

Having seen both in action (Z4 and AE900U) I was really torn. But in my situation I sit relatively close (less than 1.5x the screen width). The pixel structure on the Z4 got to me after a while, and my wife is really sensitive to it. So when the Visual Apex deal came around on the 900u I jumped on it. $1550 for a projector of this quality is hard to beat. That, and they extend your warranty by a year and give you $300 in blockbuster rentals. Not shabby.

PM if you want details on my decision process or more detailed impressions of the 900.

~Josh

 

[howie85]

just starting to research pjs now, my conclusion get the best you can afford it will hold you over longer before the upgrade bug gets to you..

 

[Hi Ho]

I agree that it is a difficult choice between the Z4 and AE900. Though I haven't seen either of those, I have seen the Sony and, though the picture was good, I won't even consider a Sony product due to their business practices. I am going to spring for a Z4 or AE900. I just want to see one in person first. I can't find anywhere to demo one.