I love car talk
The older TL's had transmission problems, so I would stay away from those (up to around 2002ish?). The NEW TL, hasn't had any recalls that I know of, but it's new.
How large of a car do you need? The IS250 is larger then your probe, but has a sportier feel, and decent power for a non track enthusiast. Good mileage too (29city, 42 hwy with the automatic). These are DI (Direct Injection) cars, so keep the revs up, otherwise carbon build up will become a big problem.
All Honda automatics mated to V6 engines from 99 to 2002 suffer from tranny issues. Stay away completely.
The IS series MPG ratings are total BS, which is unusual for Toyota since they usually underrate their cars. Expect 25/32 out of the 250 tops, 22/30 out of the 350 tops.
Don't forget about Infiniti in your considerations. IMO, they are the best bang for the buck in the luxury segment, and are very highly regarded from a quality and feature standpoint. I think, while they are nice, the BMW, Lexus, and Acura brands are overpriced.
My next car (quite a few years down the road) will likely be an Infiniti G sedan, or an M45 if I can come up with the funds
.
I must say though, I have been feeling a bit patriotic of late, and may also suggest a Lincoln MKZ or MKS, because Ford hasn't F'ed up like the rest of the American car brands, and have been running the business much better lately.
Nissan quality has decreased significantly in the past decade. Reports of even their famed VQ series engine having significant failures before the 100k mile mark turns are much more frequent now. Their trannys, both auto and stick, leave much to be desired. Just a general note. I still think they're good cars, just not on the same level quality-wise as what Honda and Toyota are putting out.
I would seriously consider test driving the G8. I know they're going away, but its a lot of car for the money and tons of fun to drive.
G8 GT is quite a car for the money. Long term, who's to say, but great car from the brand-new standpoint.
The BMW and Lexus aren't slouches, mind you, but they offer 300 hp and don't have quite as fancy drive-train treatments.
While I may differ from many, I look at performance just as much as quality and features in these cars, and Acura, Lexus, and even BMW don't offer anything that performs with the G37 in the $34k starting price range.
HP means bunk, the BMW 335i spanks everything Acura, Lexus, and Infiniti offer. Period. Straight line performance, handling, ride quality, it's got them all beat. Yes, it's more, but just illustrating the problem with quoting HP figures as rationale for purchasing. Glad you put that qualifier in there, which I bolded.
Sheep,
Do you know of any "issues" with '02-'03 Subaru WRX's?
The transmissions on the first gen USDM WRX were not bulletproof by far. In stock form they should last you for quite a long time, if you get one that hasn't been riced and run down by some 16 yr old. Believe it or not, the Lancer Evo trannies are better. Stay away from the Evo MR that's been modded, the 6 spd in those is weak and can break down even in stock form.
Shocked that no one has mentioned the Hyundai Genesis.
Genesis Coupe in 4cyl turbo trim has some weird ECU programming that cuts engine power in the middle of the powerband. It's making a lot of owners very miserable. The V6 is a sweet performance deal, and the design to me is something no one is competing with right now. If Hyundai really gets the issues worked out with the 4cyl, I'd pick up the Track model. Don't believe the hype either, the Gen Coupe 4cyl engine is NOT the Lancer Evo motor. It's a modified version of the Lancer Ralliart motor and has the fuel cutoff issue mentioned. It doesn't have Evo-level tuning capability, at least not from the factory.
That said, I would never buy a brand spanking new car. A 2-3 year old car with low miles represents the best value for money to me.
CPO represents the best value in car purchasing. New is for people that can't wait and must have the latest and greatest right now. I'll never be one of those people, I'd rather let someone else swallow the depreciation and get myself a better-than-new warranty.