you might be in trouble.  
This lady faces up to nine years in jail for just that.  [emphasis added]
"She’d reportedly rented the movie from the now-defunct Dalton Video, and never returned the cassette.
WHNS reports the store’s former owner, P.J. Dalton, had taken the matter to court nine years ago and gotten a judge to issue a warrant."
Linky 
here
No, this isn't from "The Onion".