Well, I don't really have much need for a regular switcher because I don't have dozens of devices connected. I think for me, the ability to scale the resolution would add a feature that would be of interest to a person with limited devices. I only have 4 devices and my HDTV, and only the TV and my STB are digital inputs/outputs so I don't need 4+ in/ouputs. But a switcher/scaler that doesn't cost $1000-$1400 like some *cough* HD scalers I've seen would be awesome. I just can't justify $1000 for a scaler. But, $250-$500 for a scaler outputting 1080i, up to 4 digital (HDMI, DVI, etc) outs and ins that looks sharp would be good for me.
Looks should be solid. No silver please. Or maybe silver and black versions. And it shouldn't be chunky and small, I'd rather thin and wide to go with average components. Then it would look sharp in a cabinet. If I upgrade to a HDMI/DVI DVD player, then I'd need such a switcher as my TV only has one HDMI. So this contest is actually good research as DVIGear is a respectable company in my yes.