May I ask who it was? Thanks. Igans316 (one of the most involved and obsessed over at AVS) has HK, UK, and Taiwan versions, and he thinks the UK is best. Of course, opinions vary. Of course, in the BD software forum, most are pro-video, and some think that by dropping a codec or two, the extra 10 GB for less video compression would be well worth it.
Overall, my impression is that most think the HK has the poorest video, whether it's a marginal difference or not.
I think, overall, for the money (because there might be very large differences in price), the
UK SE version might be the best value. Could be wrong.
I will keep my preorder, I think it's 3/30 release, and will cancel days before said release if my research shows I should get a different transfer.
Red Cliff: Part I and Red Cliff: Part II comparison *PIX*