I really liked it. I also have some quibbles about anachronisms but I put that aside because I liked the characters. It was great to see the old Spock back as himself and the new Spock really worked as the young guy leaning the ropes. Karl Urban was a good "bones" (he didn't remind me of Eomer at all) and Simon Pegg did a great Scotty (I've gooot to have moooore poower!). Also, finally, after all these years of diplomacy, non-interference directives, etc, the Enterprise got to obliterate some aliens, open up all the phasers, photon torpedoes and blast the suckers back to their time warp. Between Lost and Star Trek, JJ Abrams seems to really have a thing about time travel.