If your old Carver is in decent shape, it's still an excellent amp. It should easily drive a pair of BMR Towers. Why do you want to replace it?
BMR Towers are an excellent choice. I heard them last November at the Capitol Audio Fest. Personally, I think they are the best available 3-way speaker available. I haven't heard Chane A5s, so I can't comment on them.
When I heard the BMR Towers, they were driven by a very small class D amp. It was a DIY build, and contained a 2-channel NCore Hypex NC400 amp board, capable of 200 wpc. It easily drove the BMR Towers, and to my ears, it was small, powerful and silent. See my earlier post with photos from the CAF:
Monday morning after CAF … (while drinking some coffee) (Added as an Edit, because I forgot the obvious in my first draft.) I’ve heard the BMR Monitors several times, one of them in my home for several hours. I think they sound wonderful. Most of Dennis Murphy’s speakers are uncanny in how...
forums.audioholics.com
These new NCore class D amps, made by Hypex, are state of the art in amps. As you can see, they're small, lightweight, and cheap compared to old class A/B solid state amps. Presently, the best prices are from a small 1-man operation called Buckeye Amps. A 2-channel version with the NC502MP module (350w @ 8ohm, 500w @ 4ohm, 450w @ 2ohm) costs $699. With a less powerful NC252MP module (150w @ 8ohm, 250w @ 4ohm, 180w @ 2ohm) costs $529. I'd say either of these should easily drive the BMR Tower. See this link for details:
Hypex NC502MP Power Specs (1kHz, THD = 1%): - 450w @ 2ohm (per channel, peak) - 500w @ 4ohm (per channel, peak) - 350w @ 8ohm (per channel, peak) Hypex NC252MP Power Specs (1kHz, THD = 1%): - 180w @ 2ohm (per channel, peak) - 250w @ 4ohm (per channel, peak) - 150w @ 8ohm (per channel, peak) XL...
www.audiosciencereview.com
Also see
VTV Amplifiers. They sell class D amps with a wide variety of choices, including the Hypex NCores: