That brings back flashbacks of my cheap-ass father. In his retired years, he bought Barbasol in the Original scent, but only when it was on sale by the carton in a local drug store. After he died, my mother had at least a full carton of the stuff. She appealed to me to take it off her hands. It was free, so I tried using the stuff. It was alright for shaving, but I didn't like the scent, or I should say the lack of any scent. So, when my son turned 6 years old, at his birthday party (late May), we had a big shaving cream fight to use up the rest of the Barbasol.
That brings up the next topic, preferences in shaving cream. Or, as MaxInValrico has pointed out, why use any shaving cream when his wife's facial soap works?
First of all, I see two issues with shaving cream, form & function. Shaving cream's function is simply defined as: Does it allow one to shave smoothly? Form is probably best thought of as: Is it pleasant to use? That covers scent, feel or texture, and other advertising or marketing aspects.
Over the years, I have used Edge Shaving Gel, Old Spice Shaving Cream, and Gillette Series 3 (foam or gel), and finally basic Gillette Foamy. I have tried other brands, but never stayed with them. I started wet shaving using Edge, but never liked the scent. However, I did learn that the gel works better if its diluted with water. I liked Old Spice much better, and favored it for years, until it was bought by some large company. Was it also Procter & Gamble? They ruined it, and took it off the market. Ever since then, I've used one of those Gillette products I mentioned. I've learned over the years, that foams and gels are basically the same product with different amounts of water removed. Add enough water, and they are indistinguishable. As for Gillette's extensive line of shaving creams or gels, they're all the same as basic Foamy, with various additives, such as aloe or lubricants. They sell for a wide range of prices, and the cans all look quite different. All of that is marketing, and nothing else. With P&G, form prevails over function.