if "musicality" is what you care the most, NAD is significantly superioe in my opinion. I really wanted to purchase Rotel because so many people say good things about them, but then many also praise NAD. So I listened to both and the result, with no doubt in my mind, was that a NAD receiver sounds better than Rotel separates on the same speakers. I tested on classical and opera, there was just no comparison as far as fidelity was concerned. I know many might be surprised, hence ultimately my best advice for you is, take your fav's CD and go listen to both.