This is pure nonsense. It's possible for a speaker to be good for home theater impact and loudness, but that doesn't mean it will be good for music. The inverse of this is not true. If a speaker system handles music well then it is also suitable for home theater. There may only be a few exceptions to that, and Thiel is not one of them.
Not to sound arrogant, because I hope I don't have this much influence on this site to be honest, but I don't come here as often as I used to and every time I come back I see more of this "audiophile" nonsense that I had believed we where trying to stay away from. Without enough "counter intelligence" it won't be long before the average joe is taking some guy's advice on how he should crygenically freeze his single strand silver speaker wire or heaven forbid it.......phone line.
Maybe I am jumping to conclusions or think to highly of myself and hopefully I am wrong. I was just thinking it would be nice to keep the one sane forum full of diligent folks that don't have biased nonsense spilling on their keyboards and flowing into this forum.
Assuming that both the receiver and the amplifier are operating comfortably within their limits they will sound the same. The Onkyo TX-SR805 is an exceptional receiver, both as a preamp and amplifier and can deliver massive amounts of power that won't likely ever be drained by anything but the most intense loads and output situations, but I doubt most people are going to be doing concert level output in their homes.