I got it on 360. So far, I've played 7 total games (5-2) and it is my first "next-gen" football game as I've played it on PS2 for the last however many years up til last years game.
I love it. It isn't glitch free, I've missed a 54 yd field goal (shanked it off the upright) and the computer said it was good and I got 3 points. Weird. And, I've had my QB (Favre) hike the ball and then "jog" in place, with no buttons or sticks working, just him jogging there in place, until he got sacked.
But I have yet to play a sports game ever that is glitch-free.
I have had fun playing and look forward to playing it some more after work tonight. I took off work all day yesterday to get my game on. It was awesome.
Runs smooth, looks good. Real-time, real-world sportscenter updates break in when you aren't playing a game and you're just in the lobby or tweaking rosters. That caught me off guard, but it is cool.
all-in-all, i like it alot so far.