I agree with zumbo here. You must fire the subs to the rear if you expect to get the most out of them.
Also, I would ensure that the polarity/wiring on your subs is correct. To see if you may have a polarity issue, disconnect one sub from the amplifier while the system is playing. (lift a negative speaker wire from the terminal cup on one woofer). If the system immediately seems to have more bass you have a wiring/polarity problem with the subs. To correct this you will have to then determine which woofer is wired incorrectly and fix this.
You new setup should completely blow away your old one. You are running more power (Nearly 2x more) with better drivers in a better enclosure in the same space.
Can you get a closeup pic of your crossover & gain settings on the amplifier as well?
Have you taken the steps I listed out prior to ensure your system is set up fairly close to optimum?