I'll skip the HD-A2 since it's not 1080P and doesn't have 5.1 analog outputs.
Because it does 1080i, is not a reason to pass it up.
As very little can be seen from 1080i/p. (personally, I see no better smoothness)
But the 5.1 analog, is something I would want as well. (actually want 7.1 analog with the A35, at least until I get another AVR)
It is a great price, and I will probably pick one up for my brother (X-mas).
Currently having one, I will say it is not the best player, when compared to the other players I have.
But the difference is so minimal, nothing that would stop me from buying it again.