Sheep, have you actually listented to both subs, or are you speculating based on measurements? I am not trying to be an arse, I am just curious.
FR is great, and I am a big advocate of it, but if it sounds good to the individual purchasing it, then measurements don’t matter. There is no way to actually listen to every speaker/sub out there, so the measurements definitely help narrow the choices down. But there are folks out there unlike you and I that just don't care how "accurate" or realistic the system sounds. Most folks just want obnoxious boom boom blow your windows out bass. If that is what they like, then I am not going to argue with them.
.