I think people who buy AT3000s & Salon2s are buying for more reasons than just the "SQ".
I mean the top notch SQ is definitely there. But there's more to it.
And I think that is just fine and dandy. We have every right. And when we see other guys make claims like how some less expensive direct-internet sale speakers sound better, we roll our eyes like this.
And we say R-----------i------------g----------h--------------t...... whatever makes you sleep better at night buddy.
I dunno, I think people who buy Salon 2s are definitely convinced they're getting better SQ. Of the 20+ Salon 2 owners I've conversed with, none acquired them as a status symbol. I think most premium amp buyers are convinced they're getting better SQ too, but I'll stay away from any amp-related SQ judgments. The Salon 2 owners seem to be looking for very high power, like 500W+ per channel. Most roll their eyes in person or words when I mention even the ATI, so the Crown would be a bit of a surprise. In fact, sometimes I wonder if you and I are the only people running the Salon 2 with AT3000 amps.
As for the internet-direct argument, that's a tougher one I've personally wrestled with, sometimes publicly on AH. If the Phil 3 had been available *and* I had read your posts when I was in the speaker market I might had chanced ordering them. Or not, because when you're around live music a lot you know that speakers that have trouble with >105db peaks don't cut it. There's also the imaging factor, which doesn't have a signal metric. With the Salon 2 I could test the real thing and *know* the answers. With the Phil 3s, it would be an experiment. Admittedly one where the price verges on an impulse buy versus new-car money for the Salon 2. I went through the same dilemma on the DD18+ versus FW 18.0 comparison, and ended up with the DD18+, but that was only a $1K price difference. The Phil 3 - Salon 2 decision is tougher, even after your experience.
Nonetheless, I can say that if I were going through the same decision process now, after reading what you've wrote, I'd go with the $3500 experiment and sell whatever didn't work out to my satisfaction.