I’m not down playing any numbers. I’m saying the numbers that include these are still on the low end of projections. I also think is is not realistic to say none of the people would have died over the past 6 months.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Those worst case projections are really a straw man that I won't get into, as they aren't really relevant. I agree that we couldn't expect every one of those 205,000+ people to still be alive if it weren't for COVID. To get a better sense of the true mortality impact of COVID, we would need to compare the total number of deaths within any particular area/demographic over the period of the pandemic and compare that number with the same period of time/area/demographic over the average of the past...5?...10? years. Whatever the differential is will give us a better understanding of the impact.
Of course, nobody in past years died of COVID-19 and there's no question that these past few months have given us an "excess" of deaths. I'm not an actuary or statistician, so I don't know how such things are calculating. But, with fewer people commuting, there may have been fewer car accident/pedestrian deaths, which might reduce the differential. Has there been an increase in suicides because of the impact on mental health. A change in homicide rates? Those numbers would all have to be taken into account, I would think.
I don't think it's fair to dump all the blame in the US on Trump, as there have been failures on the part of the individual states, responsible federal agencies, as well as the populace at large. There have been failures on the part of many country's governments, including Canada's.
We were also slow to implement masking. Federal and provincial emergency stockpiles of N95 masks that were created after the SARS outbreak in 2002/03 expired on the shelf. Although Canada has done a better job in reducing the spread than the US, other countries, such as New Zealand and South Korea, have done better.
Canada was slower to ban travel from China than the US, because - I believe - it was seen as simplistic and racist. We restricted travel from the US last of all, despite the fact that the vast majority of our COVID cases originated from...the US.