For me if you have to struggle to notice a difference in quality, if there is any quality difference at all, it's good enough. The Marantz usually costs 300-400$ extra so in this case the denon one sounds like a better choice. I might as well use the money I save for extending the system with some extra surround or atmos speakers.
I really don't know why the digital recording quality of the vinyl was not the same... Don't get me wrong, the recording was very impressive since the quality was much better than a standard CD/SACD. He actually had the same disk in both recorded vinyl and SACD format with the latter sounding poor in comparison.
I kind of feel the same way about the SACDs I heard so far, they are not as impressive as I thought they would be but the good ones are phenomenal. I guess in the end of the day production is everything... I mean I listened to CDs which sounded better than SACDs just because the sound engineer did something right...
When I say natural I am referring to the true timbre and realistic sound of the instruments. I am a musician so I am very familiar with the sound of some instruments. Most systems (the ones I had the chance to listen to) tend to tone down instruments and as a result they sound less aggressive, lacking in attack, to sound better to our ears, but a violin during a solo or a saxophone etc are suppose to sound aggressive. Personally I did notice a difference between the two, with the instruments sounding more authentic when the vinyl was used. There were so many variables that could have played a role though... A first pressing vinyl was played using a 100K€ turntable, I don't know if we can compare that to a digital recording being played by a DAC... It's difficult to tell what made the difference though... It could be the vinyl, the turntable, the pre-amps, the amps etc etc.. There are so many variables when it comes to HiFi
I wish this is true for me too! It would save me from a lot of trouble and above all it will save me $$$$. The first thing I learned when I wandered in the dark realm of HiFi was that budget is relative
More like a couple of hundred $$$$ which would be the cost of the sound card I would have bought
I looked into the EMI noise you mentioned and sounds like it will do more harm than good....
Thank you very much guys/gals for taking the time to help me... You can't imagine how difficult it is to pick audio equipment without listening to it first...
Leave it to the Audioholics' army to save the day