While I'm all for Stalker easing up on the attitude, I am not at all for punishing him for a crime he didn't commit because he's committed others in the past. This is not justice. There are plenty of his posts that deserve an infraction (you come on a bit strong, Stalker..), the mods should go find one of those. While, at first, his post seemed rude it was realized that he was genuinely trying to help. Considering I am the member he was "rude" to, I ask the mods that his infraction be revoked.
That's not to say that I don't appreciate when the mods crack down on the more aggressive of our members, but in this case I have to speak against it.