1.incarceration protects society from the criminal, it is not a deterrent.
2. “ incarceration doesn’t work for all” neither does water...for all the good it does people drown.
3. you would never want to see innocent people put to death....then you should be against the death penalty because you KNOW innocent people have been put to death.
4. “If there's no place for capital punishment in a modern advanced society, why should murder and other terrible crimes have a place?”
as intelligent as you are....really?
Well, if you think letting violent criminals out early is protecting people, we have different definitions of the word 'protect'. They also offer council and education in prisons but many don't bother with it because, in some cases, returning to their life outside is more lucrative and they get street cred from going to prison. Someone announced that seven inmates will be leaving with associate degrees- not a bad thing if they don't use it to further their criminal lives. Rehab need to increase/improve- many people just don't know how to live outside of the prison without getting into trouble.
Drowning in/from water is from misuse.
I'm against the flawed system that doesn't make sure people aren't put to death- if there's any doubt, they need to take more time. It's a fine line- is there any benefit from allowing someone to live after they murdered several people, or did something terrible? Do the victims and their families have any rights? Should society keep someone alive for decades when they'll never be getting out?
A good example is Jeffrey Dahmer- if his death wasn't sanctioned by the authorities, it would have been due to his preying on minorities. Another inmate was killed during the same incident.
By not dealing with the problems behind murder and other terrible crimes, those crimes will never stop. People make the choice to do things, but it's often just a reaction at the time. Milwaukee and other US cities have had many children killed in shootouts involving drug dealers and gangs- all they needed to do is go to an isolated place, but they chose to do it in residential areas. One 5 year old girl was sitting on her grandfather's lap as he read to her- why did that need to happen?
People could be so much better, but they don't seem to want to- criminal activity in some families is generational and I can give an example, based on someone who stole something from me- his dad, son and grandson all have a criminal record. Not terribly violent, but the pattern was set.
It's not that I want people to be put to death, I just want people to stop being turds.
Your perspective, is one of the reasons I don't plan to stay in Milwaukee much longer.