Thanks for clarifying what happened. So that court thinks that being convicted of business fraud is enough without any other monetary penalty. WOW. :mad: What if it is appealed to the NY supreme court? Can a fine be imposed? The appeals court is turning over the decision of what they call Supreme Court in NY....the appeals court is effectively the supreme court in other jurisdictions. https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/8jd/structure.shtml