
Rob Babcock
Moderator
I didn't get a chance to see The Dark Knight in the theater so I'm pretty stoked to pick it up on DVD.
What it comes down to, is these guys are literally TRYING to find flaws. Yes, those add up to somewhat of a loss in total PQ, but ultimately when I look at those comparisons, what I still see is that the BD is quite a bit better than the DVD. As long as it looks and sounds good, I will be satisfied, because I enjoyed the movie. While I do notice the difference between a great transfer and a bad one, if I like the movie, it matters a lot lessThanks your input here, j. Ya know, this is the ONLY movie I saw in the theater this year. I thought to myself that I should have waited for the BD, because I fully predicted it would look so much better at home.
While that may or may not be the case, you do have a point about the darker color palette. OTOH, some dark films like the Underworld series look very, very good.
I notice this type of stuff. Admittedly, I am trying to do it to a lesser extent. Still, I do try to support better transfers with my money when I can. In this case, I want the movie anyways, and I will end up supporting a less than ideal transfer, which I am led to believe did not have to be the case.
And if my PQ expectations are to be lowered, I do hope to be more easily satisfied.![]()
You are too crazy.I will be going out at midnight to get mine
DVD? Yuck!I didn't get a chance to see The Dark Knight in the theater so I'm pretty stoked to pick it up on DVD.
I bought Batman Begins just to see that sceneI will be going out at midnight to get mine---thats for sure. I'm just stoked to have the experience at home....although seeing at the IMAX here in Houston was pretty spectacular....Oh I will interested to see what the do with the IMAX scenes. If you looked through any of the extras on the Batman Begins Blu-ray they put that entire opening scene that is on IMAX as an extra and I thought it looked fantastic....
In other words, I don't think we have a lot to worry about in terms of PQThe 35mm-based footage is certainly no slouch, but there is an added sharpness and depth to the IMAX-originated footage that raises the bar for what Blu-ray is capable of.
That said, the whole of the transfer is excellent. The source is absolutely spotless, with no defects and a smooth, clean veneer. Blacks are quite simply the richest I think I've seen on a Blu-ray, and contrast is never too hot or too flat. The image pops with wonderful depth -- it is never less than three-dimensional -- yet remains natural and appealing. Color saturation is likewise rich, with splashes of deep primaries and not a hint of chroma noise, bleeding or smearing. Fleshtones are also accurate, except in situations of intentional stylization. Shadow delineation is also exemplary, with even the darkest areas brimming with fine textures and detail.
Unfortunately, my caveat is that there is edge enhancement that results in visible edge halos. While the encode is otherwise rock solid -- I found no artifacts, such as aliasing or pixelization -- the edge enhancement, if slight, is clearly visible in longer shots (such as the parade sequence). It is the only element of this presentation that deserves any knocks, though hardly a fatal flaw. In all other respects, 'The Dark Knight' is a stunner.