surround speaker question

selkec

selkec

Audioholic
Does it really matter if the surround speakers are matching in brand. I know it does with the front 3 speakers with timbre matching but how important is it for surround speakers. I will addd that I do not listen to multi channel music. Only used for HT use.
 
XEagleDriver

XEagleDriver

Audioholic Chief
Not really

Does it really matter if the surround speakers are matching in brand. I know it does with the front 3 speakers with timbre matching but how important is it for surround speakers. I will addd that I do not listen to multi channel music. Only used for HT use.
Selkec,

For your application (HT and not MC music) it does not really matter.

If your AVR or pre-amp allows you to set different crossover frequencies for different speaker sets (front, surrounds, rears) you have even more flexability to mix and match speaker types/sizes.

My touch of OCD, plus an afinity for MC music, causes me to use same brand, model series, and woofer size in all my speakers--but that is not your situation.

Cheers,
XEagleDriver
 
son-yah-tive

son-yah-tive

Full Audioholic
I did, just to be safe. And also in 5Ch mode they all sound great together.
 
Halon451

Halon451

Audioholic Samurai
Currently I use a different brand as my surrounds, but that's soon to change. Have really had zero complaints with this arrangement for HT use, although on a more subtle level I just crave the consistency of a well rounded system with matching speakers all around. I rarely listen to any multi-channel music, as such any music listening I do is usually in 2-ch stereo mode anyway.

The general consensus is to ensure your front three are matched at least, since this is where most of the sound in a standard 5.1 track comes from. This gives you a more consistent SQ as the audio pans across the front back and forth, while the surrounds are mainly for effects sounds and such.
 
selkec

selkec

Audioholic
Thanks everyone. I ask because Im living in an apartment and I think having 4 of Polks biggest towers is too much. I ended up with this setup because my want to have wood grain speakers and not black and Frys had an awesome deal on Polk rtia9's in cherry at Christmas. I had to get them and that freed up my original polk towers. Now Im thinking of selling my rts150's to a friend and looking at different surrounds. Im also loking at dipole/bipole surrounds. Polk makes some but only in black or white. I want cherry. So that brought me to the axiom site looking t the Qs8's. Which would fit my situation perfectly plus I like their design of quad directional sound.
So does anyone know how axiom compare to polk in sound. I think I have heard they are bright which most also say about Polk.
 
J

jostenmeat

Audioholic Spartan
Thanks everyone. I ask because Im living in an apartment and I think having 4 of Polks biggest towers is too much. I ended up with this setup because my want to have wood grain speakers and not black and Frys had an awesome deal on Polk rtia9's in cherry at Christmas. I had to get them and that freed up my original polk towers. Now Im thinking of selling my rts150's to a friend and looking at different surrounds. Im also loking at dipole/bipole surrounds. Polk makes some but only in black or white. I want cherry. So that brought me to the axiom site looking t the Qs8's. Which would fit my situation perfectly plus I like their design of quad directional sound.
So does anyone know how axiom compare to polk in sound. I think I have heard they are bright which most also say about Polk.
That is a lot of money to spend for mismatching surrounds, no? I've done mismatched surrounds, and it works perfectly well for HT, but then I ended up matching them in the end. After that experience, I will always try to match if at all possible. And while I've probably now seen hundreds of movies on my PJ setup, my new must-see bluray for new guests is now actually a classical music concert bluray, where before that might have been Rataouille, or The Dark Knight, or Kill Bill, etc.

IMHO, it's not necessarily worth spending so much for bipoles/dipoles, of course, only in relation to one's total budget for the entire HT. Monopoles work great too for much less cost, particularly if it's a small viewing area and/or the room setup doesn't allow for such designs. Dipoles need to be placed so that you sit in the null, and bipoles depend more on boundary interaction than monopoles. BTW, I currently have bipole side surrounds.
 
selkec

selkec

Audioholic
I think for now ill stick with my rti150's as rears since they are tll enough towers that the tweets and mids can reach over the top of my couch. Plus I guess this way I can get an amp for my rears and have really kick ars multi channel music if I ever try it. It just seems like alot of speakers in one room in an apartment. Its 5 of polks biggest rti line speakers in one apartment living room. It rattles everything. Good thing my neighbors are young. No complaints yet.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top