Sierra-1 or B&W CM5 for computer music set-up

R

RipcordAFF

Audioholic Intern
I am thinking about upgrading my nearfield computer set-up. Currently, I have a Peachtree Decco2 and AV123 ELT-525 speakers. I think my electronics will end up being a Rotel amp paired with a Burson HA-160D for headphones and DAC duties. The speakers are where I am having trouble.

At one point I was certain to go with the newer Ascend Sierra-1 NrT. Reviews seem to be positive and I know that they have long, positive history here on AH. However, I really don't fancy the looks. The drivers and cabinets don't do it for me. Further, with the NrT upgrade, they are getting up there, I think around 1300 a pair.

Another option that I am heavily considering is the B&W CM5. Absolutely gorgeous. They would end up being slightly more expensive, but they certainly look it. There aren't nearly as many reviews out there and the ones that I have found are "different" than the Sierra reviews. While most of the Sierra reviews talk about it dominating its price bracket (at that time, sub $1k), the B&W reviews generally say it performs well within its price bracket (sub $2k bookshelves).

So I am kind of lost. Its going to be a 100% music application, likely with no sub. I am just having a hard time comparing the top-of-the-line offering from an ID company to the lower end offering of a venerable company such as B&W.

Any thoughts would be appreciated!
 
digicidal

digicidal

Full Audioholic
Do you already have the Rotel and Burson? I would recommend looking as some of the higher-end active studio monitors as potentially a better solution. You can always have a separate DAC/Headphone amp for 'quiet times', but for the cost of the Rotel and either of the passives you have listed, you could get a pair of really nice monitors.

I forget the exact model, but KEW (I think) reviewed a set of the Focal BE actives on here and preferred them to some very stiff competition. They would definitely be beyond the price of the Sierras/B&Ws - however, for the cost of the Rotel they would be pretty close. He indicates the MSRP at ~$2500 IIRC and I'm sure you could find some used with some patience for under $2K. Just a thought. I've spent quite some time with the CM5's (granted in a non-perfect setup - Magnolia) and although I found them to be very nice looking speakers - I actually doubt that they sound better than the sierra's with the upgrades. I found them to have a rather 'veiled' sound - almost as if the mids were a little congested. You might love them however - so I'd try to find someone with Sierra's near you if possible and give them a listen.

I'll look for that link.

EDIT: Found it here -> HERE
 
Last edited:
lsiberian

lsiberian

Audioholic Overlord
For a computer I would prefer the smaller ascends myself.
 
E

EJD

Junior Audioholic
I really like the CM5s, and the Ascends are on my audition list as well, so I really doubt you could go wrong with either.

Just to throw another suggestion out there - check into Peachtree's D5s (or D4s) as well. I have the ERA D4 (previous name of the same speaker) and it's pretty shocking how good these are. Bass response is far, far beyond what you would expect.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top