Rush Clockwork Angles

stevied

stevied

Audioholics Brewmaster
So, I sprung for the new Rush Album, "Clockwork Angles." I listened carefully to the entire CD. As pronounced in a Jewish stereo type voice while shrugging my shoulders and holding out my hands sideways; "Meh."

Be ready for some of the same-ole-same-ole. As much as Neil Pert is amazing as always, the songs are simply just mediocre at best. I'm not looking for another pop song, but Clockwork Angles provides nothing memorable, nothing radio friendly, nothing that will survive time. No Limelight or Test for Echos or Red Barchetta, just song after song of "meh" with some special moments in a few songs. Although it's a different concept album, it follows in the footsteps of every other song they have done since Presto. The diehards will eat it up as always, but this will probably collect dust in my oversized collection of music. Alex Lifeson sounds exactly the same on guitar as he has always done on every single song he has ever played since his inception. He's never done anything inventive, so don't look for it here. You would think with all the years of experience, he may change the sound of his guitar and style of playing on at least one song, but......NOPE. Oh, Getty Lee did discover using a volume horn while singing in certain parts of a song. He must have learned that from JD on Rock Star INXS.

More importantly, the engineering of this CD is simply horrible. Clearly mixed for the iPod user. Nothing but over compressed mushy cymbals over screechy guitars and three note synth playing all in the same frequency range with absolutely no dynamics.

Hey, you know what Rush becomes without Neil Pert? A Garage Band.

Don't get me wrong. The CD has it's moments, but moments are far and few between. The band hasn't been relevant in over 15 years and this CD is nothing more but the same old recycle material, including expressions like, "machinery, spirit, synchronized, mystery, floating.......They seem to use these words like others use "the" and "it."

Now, where's my Porcupine Tree CD?
 
gene

gene

Audioholics Master Chief
Administrator
So, I sprung for the new Rush Album, "Clockwork Angles." I listened carefully to the entire CD. As pronounced in a Jewish stereo type voice while shrugging my shoulders and holding out my hands sideways; "Meh."

Be ready for some of the same-ole-same-ole. As much as Neil Pert is amazing as always, the songs are simply just mediocre at best. I'm not looking for another pop song, but Clockwork Angles provides nothing memorable, nothing radio friendly, nothing that will survive time. No Limelight or Test for Echos or Red Barchetta, just song after song of "meh" with some special moments in a few songs. Although it's a different concept album, it follows in the footsteps of every other song they have done since Presto. The diehards will eat it up as always, but this will probably collect dust in my oversized collection of music. Alex Lifeson sounds exactly the same on guitar as he has always done on every single song he has ever played since his inception. He's never done anything inventive, so don't look for it here. You would think with all the years of experience, he may change the sound of his guitar and style of playing on at least one song, but......NOPE. Oh, Getty Lee did discover using a volume horn while singing in certain parts of a song. He must have learned that from JD on Rock Star INXS.

More importantly, the engineering of this CD is simply horrible. Clearly mixed for the iPod user. Nothing but over compressed mushy cymbals over screechy guitars and three note synth playing all in the same frequency range with absolutely no dynamics.

Hey, you know what Rush becomes without Neil Pert? A Garage Band.

Don't get me wrong. The CD has it's moments, but moments are far and few between. The band hasn't been relevant in over 15 years and this CD is nothing more but the same old recycle material, including expressions like, "machinery, spirit, synchronized, mystery, floating.......They seem to use these words like others use "the" and "it."

Now, where's my Porcupine Tree CD?
Porcupine Tree and Steve Wilson are beyond CD, their stuff is all multi channel now including Wilson's latest solo effort which was released in Blu-ray and is excellent!

I can't listen to Rush anymore (at least their stuff after the late 90s), sorry Rush fans.
 
stevied

stevied

Audioholics Brewmaster
Rush Clockwork Recycle

They should have called the new CD what it really is. Clockwork Recycle.
 
STRONGBADF1

STRONGBADF1

Audioholic Spartan
Originally Posted by stevied View Post
So, I sprung for the new Rush Album, "Clockwork Angles." I listened carefully to the entire CD. As pronounced in a Jewish stereo type voice while shrugging my shoulders and holding out my hands sideways; "Meh."
It is not epic, and if you are not a Rush fan already this album will do nothing for you. (although my wife said "it's not bad" and she is not a Rush fan.)

Be ready for some of the same-ole-same-ole. As much as Neil Pert is amazing as always, the songs are simply just mediocre at best. I'm not looking for another pop song, but Clockwork Angles provides nothing memorable, nothing radio friendly, nothing that will survive time. No Limelight or Test for Echos or Red Barchetta, just song after song of "meh" with some special moments in a few songs. Although it's a different concept album, it follows in the footsteps of every other song they have done since Presto. The diehards will eat it up as always, but this will probably collect dust in my oversized collection of music. Alex Lifeson sounds exactly the same on guitar as he has always done on every single song he has ever played since his inception. He's never done anything inventive, so don't look for it here. You would think with all the years of experience, he may change the sound of his guitar and style of playing on at least one song, but......NOPE. Oh, Getty Lee did discover using a volume horn while singing in certain parts of a song. He must have learned that from JD on Rock Star INXS.
This has got to be the easiest album Neil has ever done...He played well but was far from his usual "amazing" IMO.

Rush hasn't relied on radio airplay ever and I don't think they are looking for it now...especially with a concept album. I do think "Headlong Flight" could be received well on radio but it's too long for them.

Most guitarists develop a signature sound and Lifeson is no different but listen again. He used quite a few new sounds and styles. Also, He has influenced countless guitar players... You really need to listen to the Rush catalog and rediscover how insanely good he has been through the years. "La Villa Strangiato" should be enough though.

More importantly, the engineering of this CD is simply horrible. Clearly mixed for the iPod user. Nothing but over compressed mushy cymbals over screechy guitars and three note synth playing all in the same frequency range with absolutely no dynamics.
I'm not impressed with the over all sound quality either. That's been a problem for Rush and most hard rock bands forever.

Hey, you know what Rush becomes without Neil Pert? A Garage Band.
Wow...:rolleyes:


Don't get me wrong. The CD has it's moments, but moments are far and few between. The band hasn't been relevant in over 15 years and this CD is nothing more but the same old recycle material, including expressions like, "machinery, spirit, synchronized, mystery, floating.......They seem to use these words like others use "the" and "it."
I do agree that the CD has moments and I wish they would have expounded on those moments a little more.

Now, where's my Porcupine Tree CD?
Hey, I like Porcupine Tree too but don't rag on Rush for repetitions on a theme and then say where's my Porcupine Tree CD. That's just the pot calling the kettle black. Rush and PT aren't even the same type of music.


Yes, I am a rush fan and have been since about 1981, but I have never pushed Rush or even tried to explain them unless asked. They are just an odd flavor for most and that's fine. To each their own. I understand that they have had a long career with changes along the way and some fans only like certain periods of Rush if at all. I'm odd that I like all the stages of Rush. the early stuff is the best for me but I still find the middle periods better than 99% of all else out there and the stuff since Vapor Trails is mostly just average with some very good highlights thrown in.


Don't get me wrong, you are very entitled to your opinion but some of what you said is just a little over zealous and over the top if not just wrong.:)

Now, wheres my Rush CD at.;):) I'll listen to some PT later too!:cool:
 
gene

gene

Audioholics Master Chief
Administrator
Hey, I like Porcupine Tree too but don't rag on Rush for repetitions on a theme and then say where's my Porcupine Tree CD. That's just the pot calling the kettle black. Rush and PT aren't even the same type of music.
Actually I believe Porcupine Tree's biggest influence was King Crimson, Pink Floyd and to some extent Rush. I'd classify all of these bands as Progressive Rock though Porcupine Tree has a touch of metal thrown in.

Great points regarding the rest of your post however.
 
96cobra10101

96cobra10101

Senior Audioholic
I'm a huge fan, but I'm a bit disappointed in Clockwork, but I think part of it is they set the bar pretty high with S&A a few years back. I'll definitely give it a few more listens, but it'll probably end up sitting next Vapor Trails, my other least favorite Rush album. My other gripe is that the audio quality is also lacking, reminds me of Presto which was released about 25 years ago.
 
STRONGBADF1

STRONGBADF1

Audioholic Spartan
Actually I believe Porcupine Tree's biggest influence was King Crimson, Pink Floyd and to some extent Rush. I'd classify all of these bands as Progressive Rock though Porcupine Tree has a touch of metal thrown in.

Great points regarding the rest of your post however.
Thanks Gene.

To clarify my opinion. Porcupine Tree and Rush are both progressive but their styles are not alike. Both good bands drummers I like to listen to though. Semantics I know, but still my opinion.:)
 
C

Cygnus

Senior Audioholic
I really like Clockwork angels as well. It's much better than their last record, Snakes and Arrows, that's for sure. They've still got it, and they have been relevant for the last 15 years. To this day, they still sell out everywhere they play, after all.
 
D

deedubb

Full Audioholic
I really like Clockwork angels as well. It's much better than their last record, Snakes and Arrows, that's for sure. They've still got it, and they have been relevant for the last 15 years. To this day, they still sell out everywhere they play, after all.
I actually like Snakes and Arrows much more than any of their recent stuff. I bought Clockwork Angels as soon as it was out, but sadly, it's sitting idle at the moment while the new Linkin Park and Cranberries CD's are getting all of my attention. I did have a quick listen to Clockwork Angels but it didn't impress me enough to go back into the CD player. Their stuff always grows on me though. I just have to get sick of the other stuff I'm listening to before I will listen to it again.
 
96cobra10101

96cobra10101

Senior Audioholic
I actually like Snakes and Arrows much more than any of their recent stuff. I bought Clockwork Angels as soon as it was out, but sadly, it's sitting idle at the moment while the new Linkin Park and Cranberries CD's are getting all of my attention. I did have a quick listen to Clockwork Angels but it didn't impress me enough to go back into the CD player. Their stuff always grows on me though. I just have to get sick of the other stuff I'm listening to before I will listen to it again.
I think S&A is awesome, much better than Vapor Trails. I've listened to Clockwork a few more times and its starting to grow on me.
 
djreef

djreef

Audioholic Chief
Has anyone picked up the hi-rez version through download yet? I was thinking of getting it just for the helluvit to see if the sq was really any better.

DJ
 
STRONGBADF1

STRONGBADF1

Audioholic Spartan
Has anyone picked up the hi-rez version through download yet? I was thinking of getting it just for the helluvit to see if the sq was really any better.

DJ
No...I'd like a bluray version though.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top