Purchasing speakers dilemma!

Mog

Mog

Audioholic Intern
I am a Audioholic Virgin so be gentle. I now have Bose dual cubes in a 5.1 setup with a Klipsch 10" subwoofer for my LFE and a Sony ES STR-DA2400 receiver.

For some reason it just doesn't excite me anymore. I am looking to purchase the Mirage MX 5.1, but I hear the Nanosats have better sound quality, any suggestions?
 
F

fredk

Audioholic General
Listen to them. Better yet, listen to a bunch of different speakers in your budged and even a few slightly above that budget.
 
Mog

Mog

Audioholic Intern
I read it and I know Bose are just wall decorations that aren't pleasing to the eye, but my dilemma is,

Mirage MX 5.1 or nanosats? I have seen all the "magazine" reviews, just wondered if a consumer has advice? Thanks for the reply.
 
CraigV

CraigV

Audioholic General
The mirage disperse sound over a very large area. The effect is a very large soundstage, but not so tight focus & imaging. I too suggest listening to a lot of different speakers in your budget.
 
J

jamie2112

Banned
If I were you I would stop dragging the Mirage in the picture and get out and LISTEN to a few speakers before you buy something you might not be happy with a few months down the road......IMO of course...
 
F

FirstReflection

AV Rant Co-Host
Whelp, the reason your Bose cubes fail to excite you is because they are terrible speakers. Sadly, you likely paid several hundred dollars for about $8 worth of speakers, which is how Bose manages to advertise EVERYWHERE and buy entire sections of stores to create the illusion that they are "high end".

Virtually anything will be better than Bose, including the Mirage speakers that seem to have caught your fancy. Based upon what you have expressed so far, I am assuming you are drawn to very compact, physically tiny speakers. The downside with that aesthetic is that compromises are unavoidable. Speakers are literally just pumps that move air and tiny speakers cannot move sufficient amounts of air to recreate sound in a natural and authentic manner.

You would be MUCH better served if you could bring yourself to consider a different aesthetic. Perhaps you wouldn't mind some slick-looking, fairly thin speakers that can be mounted to the wall? While fairly thin speaker are necessarily compromised as well, they can, at least, make use of larger drivers to move a more reasonable quantity of air.

Another option could be in-wall speakers or in-wall/on-wall hybrids.

Here are some speaker packages that I can recommend to you. These should be around your budget and while they are not tiny (like the Bose cubes or the Mirage speakers), they are certainly not large either:

- "The Speaker Company" TSAT2000 system

and if you find the TSAT2000 speakers too large, there is a smally version with the TSAT1000 speakers

- "Axiom Audio" In-wall/On-wall hybrid speakers

- "EMP Tek" Compact Home Theatre

I would personally look to any of those before I would go for the Mirage speakers. The Mirage speakers are just too diffuse to really deliver proper sound imaging and detail IMO. Particularly for videogames, it is important to be able to pin-point the direction and location of sounds. The Mirage speakers just make everything a large, mushy, diffuse mess IMO.
 
H

Highbar

Senior Audioholic
What is your budget? Why are you just looking at Mirage? Are they the only speakers in your area? Reading about speakers and listening to what others say is great but when it comes down to it only YOUR ears can tell you what sounds good. Get out there and listen to as much as you can. If you give us a budget we can give you some brands to start with, without just listen to every thing you can and start from there.
 
F

fredk

Audioholic General
If you are really down to those two, then listen to them both and pick the one you like better.

It migh also help you if you could quantify why you don't like your current setup. Of course, going out and listening to other speakers would greatly help there. ;)
 
Mog

Mog

Audioholic Intern
Thanks for all of the great advice. My current Bose set up lacks range. I like to hear Mids not just highs and lows. I have a budget around 1200. The reason I am drawn to satellite speakers are I like to have nice sounding speakers that don't look like furniture, I like a sleek hidden design that when people watch a movie they are wondering where all that sound is coming from.
 
A

ack_bak

Audioholic
Thanks for all of the great advice. My current Bose set up lacks range. I like to hear Mids not just highs and lows. I have a budget around 1200. The reason I am drawn to satellite speakers are I like to have nice sounding speakers that don't look like furniture, I like a sleek hidden design that when people watch a movie they are wondering where all that sound is coming from.
Have you considered in-wall speakers with paintable grills?
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top