pros and cons of dual 8s

TLS Guy

TLS Guy

Audioholic Jedi
are you talking about one on one: say 10" vs. 15"
or are you talking about triple 10"ers vs. a single 15"er?
In terms of depth the answer is that the F3 point is not related to driver diameter. However to achieve equivalent spl you will likely need multiples unless you build a driver with very large xmax. In other words two 8s to get the spl of a 12 and two 10s to get the spl of a 15. However one 8 can have the same F3 as a 15. F3 is determined by Fs and compliance with correct loading. No where does the speaker diameter enter into the equation for the lowest note a speaker can produce. I have never been fond of 15 drivers and I will always opt to design for two 10 inch over one 15 inch.
 
E

Exit

Audioholic Chief
Subwoofer size proportional to room size

Some small subwoofers (cone diameters) can play lower than larger ones. The thing is that small subwoofers can work well in small rooms. When you put small subwoofers in large rooms, they can’t move enough air to get sufficient SPL and they tend to bottom out when the sound source is most demanding, unless they have good built-in limiters but when limiters kick in that affects sound quality in other ways.

Larger speakers are needed for larger rooms and in general it is easier for the better designers to get better low extension out of larger subwoofers. I think you can see this most clearly in the Velodyne speaker product line but also in other product lines as well. In smaller rooms, bigger speakers can be turned down, but I can imagine there could be an overkill situation there too where the room is pressurized to an uncomfortable point or the subwoofers are sized to the point they take up too much space of a small room.

I would suggest overall that the subwoofer(s) should be proportional to the room size. The other speakers should also be sized proportional to the room size as smaller cube or spherical speakers may not have enough SPL capability to fill a large room without straining or distortion.

Just my observations from experience.
 
cerwinmad

cerwinmad

Full Audioholic
yes i agree, i have the the fronts set to large to back up the sub, as set on large the twelves produce a good solid low end. i have the sub set -3db compared to the fronts to balance it out. the VE-12s handle ALOT of power.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top