Thats it Greg, no scotch for you tonight. Or was that double scotch? I always get the two confused.
Minus, I agree. Some people just don't like vinyl.
Two of the finishes I saw during my factory tour, high gloss cherry and hg burled walnut, were both indistinguishable from the real thing unless you looked very, very closely. I saw both beside their real wood counterparts. Its really quite impressive what can be done with vinyl these days.
Now, if you were able to get an oil finish on speakers, I think it would make a big difference as oil seems to really add depth to the grain that you couldn't replicate in any artificial finish.