I disagree!
I learned to drive on a 4 speed renault 5 (le car, as it was called in the U.S.), I actually like driving a stick. But I also drive through heavy traffic often and that's when the fun ends. Tiptronic brings SOME of the fun of the stick shift, but only when you want it. Formula 1 race cars actually have paddles at the wheel to shift up and down, no cluth and stick; so tiptronic is more like an F1 than a traditional stick.