Movies: Starke v BIC PL-300

[Cranky Chain Cycles]

Starke SW15 v BIC PL-300. 15" v 12" for movies. I'm more interested in accuracy than size. Both are recommended. I'm leaning more towards the Starke if I only have 1 for a basement setup. Current subs are 10" Klipsch.

 

[NINaudio]

Personally I'd go with the Starke. Both models have ben reviewed on audioholics, so you can easily compare the two, but the Starke has a flatter response and IMO is the better looking of the two.

 

[lovinthehd]

The SW12 might be more comparable but comparing a sealed and ported sub can often simply come down to size. Are you limited in box size? Why only one sub?