Iron Man BD SQ not as loud as SD DVD?

AcuDefTechGuy

AcuDefTechGuy

Audioholic Jedi
Quote from DVDTown.com review of Iron Man BD:

"I compared several passages to the regular Dolby Digital 5.1 track on the standard-def version of the movie, and, sure enough, the SD disc had the punchier sound. I also compared the TrueHD and regular Dolby Digital tracks (for French and Spanish) on the Blu-ray disc itself and found the TrueHD sounding a bit lower in output. But even when level-matched, the TrueHD sounded slightly wimpier to me. I can't explain why it's happening, nor can I tell you which version is more true to the movie's original soundtrack. I can only describe what I hear, and what I hear makes me favor the regular Dolby Digital, at least in regard to its seemingly wider, more-potent dynamics.

Audio addendum: Not trusting my ears, I used a sound-level meter to test the difference in one of the softest and loudest passages on the disc. I chose scene fourteen, when Pepper is speaking to Tony on the telephone, and as the reference passage I chose the line "Odadiah, he's gone insane," which I set for 70 db. Then I measured the appearance of the villain, crashing very loudly through the basement roof. In TrueHD, the difference in loudness was +24 db, the villain producing a noise level of 94 db (compared to the 70 db for Pepper's line). Then I measured the same line from Pepper and the same crashing through the basement roof in regular Dolby Digital from the standard-definition disc. The loudness difference this time in regular Dolby Digital was +28 db, about four decibels greater in regular DD."
 
mike c

mike c

Audioholic Warlord
if true, that sucks. i've held all my online movie orders anticipating the release of Iron Man.
 
GlocksRock

GlocksRock

Audioholic Spartan
Not that big of a deal really... that's what the volume knob is for.
 
obscbyclouds

obscbyclouds

Senior Audioholic
Sounds suspicious to me.

Just because it's louder doesn't mean it'll sound better. Some people do prefer the volume compression and thing it is "punchier". There's a reason the loudness wars exist in the CD world.

In my own experience I've often found that uncompressed music and movies need to be turned up louder to achieve the same sound, as they seem to have a lower noise floor.
 
Sheep

Sheep

Audioholic Warlord
Sounds suspicious to me.

Just because it's louder doesn't mean it'll sound better. Some people do prefer the volume compression and thing it is "punchier". There's a reason the loudness wars exist in the CD world.

In my own experience I've often found that uncompressed music and movies need to be turned up louder to achieve the same sound, as they seem to have a lower noise floor.
I have to agree. Loudness is used as an attention getter. This is also severely subjective.

SheepStar
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Not that big of a deal really... that's what the volume knob is for.
I think the reviewer may be refering to dynamic compression. Watch Live Free Die Hard on Blu-ray and you will understand the meaning of good dynamics.;)
 
GlocksRock

GlocksRock

Audioholic Spartan
I have Live Free Or Die Hard on Blu Ray, and actually just used that to demo my system for a friend who stopped by. Needless to say he was very impressed.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top