Iron Maiden - Edward The Great - CD review.

Rock&Roll Ninja

Rock&Roll Ninja

Audioholic Field Marshall
Artist: Iron Maiden
Album: Edward The Great(2002 EMI records)

Introduction: Iron Maiden, a heavy metal band, was formed in the early 80's and have produced at least 15 albums for labels including EMI, Sony, Columbia, Epic, and Virgin. They failed to attain major radio play in the US, mainly because of their openly occult material (they have an album titles Number Of The Beast how could conservative Regan-era middle America not be saturated with them?!?!?), never achieved the success of, say, Judas Priest or Led Zepplin. Never-the-less Maiden has produced an impressive back catalog of heavy metal songs including The Trooper, Run To The Hills, and Fear Of The Dark.

BTW; The album title is refrence to Iron Maiden's mascot "Eddie", a rather corpsified gent, a character whom has no thematic connection to the material (aside from the album cover), at least as far as this compilation is concerned.

Track List

1. Run To The Hills
2. Number Of The Beast
3. Flight Of Icarus
4. The Trooper
5. 2 Minutes To Midnight
6. Wasted Years
7. Can I Play With Madness
8. The Evil That Men Do
9. The Clairvoyant
10. Infinite Dreams
11. Holy Smoke
12. Bring Your Daughter ... To The Slaughter
13. Man On Edge
14. Futureal
15. The Wicker Man
16. Fear Of The Dark (Live cut).

Audio Quality: Awful. :( From its horribly cut dynamic range (the opening "satanic chant" from Number Of The Beast is barely any softer than the songs amplified guitar!) to its "everything dead center" soundstage, it would appear the mixers employed by EMI for this project take a special sadistic delight in making the material as dull and lifeless as possible. Even the drums sound like wooden spoons being pushed into mashed potatos, I honestly couldn't tell the drummer apart from the bassist during most of the material. Seriously, it sounds like a $30 Casio electric keyboard doing all the drum work. The live cut (track 16) seems to have not been re-engineered for suckyness and only serves to whet your appetite for what could have been a very good listening experience overall.

Summary: I like this material. I never had any experience with Maiden before, I think my brother had a Stranger In A Strange Land T-shirt at one point. I thouroughly enjoyed the music, from Icarus to Infinite Dreams I was impressed with much of the work that Radio & MTV has ignored for years. True Diehard Maiden fans will doubtlessly own all the albums already, making a 'greatest hits' compilation not needed. And for semi-regular fans of Maiden there is the 2 Disc The Essential Iron Maiden collection issued by Sony records. But this smaller single disc set is good for people looking to get a foot into the door of Maiden's lengthy released material. So while the material is good, I cannot recommend the CD because the sound quality is so damn poor.
 
M

MDS

Audioholic Spartan
It's the only 'greatest hits' compilation that includes Flight of Icarus and that's pretty much the only reason I bought it. I have all of the other songs I like on other discs.

I don't recall the sound quality being that poor, although I never listened to it on the real stereo. I just ripped the tracks and saved them on my external hard drive.
 
Paulvader

Paulvader

Junior Audioholic
I have been a big fan for 21 years now. They actually had formed most of the regular line-up in the late 70's. The album Edward the Great is just one of their "Greatest Hits" that they seem to release every few years lately. I haven't actually heard that album so I can't comment on the quality of the recording. They have 23 album releases of which 12 are studio albums. They IMO generally have amazing production to their material. The Rock In Rio DVD is just excellent. They have a new DVD being released Feb.6th which I've been told is just as good. It is unfortunate that their music isn't accepted in North America as stated by Rock&Roll Ninja as much as the rest of the world - they are an amazing live show - tons of energy on stage. I was fortunate enough to see them live in 1986 and again this year in Toronto and the next day in Detroit as part of Ozzfest (which due to Ozzy Ozbourne not being able to perform with the rest of Black Sabbath) pretty much took the festival over in various citites. They are lucky enough to have rebounded in popularity in recent years with the rejoining of Bruce Dickinson and guitarist Adrian Smith back to the line up. O.K. enough of my rant and sorry to throw the review of Ed The Great off topic..lol...:rolleyes: Just happy to see a thread about one of the greatest bands to come out of England IMO!!!
 
jonnythan

jonnythan

Audioholic Ninja
Paulvader said:
The Rock In Rio DVD is just excellent.
I can't wait to fire up that DVD once I have my home theater set up. I've seen them three times, and they're easily my favorite band of all time.

Oh yeah :cool:
 
Paulvader

Paulvader

Junior Audioholic
jonnythan said:
I can't wait to fire up that DVD once I have my home theater set up. I've seen them three times, and they're easily my favorite band of all time.

Oh yeah :cool:

The new DVD coming out is from 2003 in Germany..."Death on the Road"...I just received Judas Priest "Rising In The East" from Bodukan in 2005 and am waiting for the Maiden and Deep Purple DVD's I've ordered. I told the wife to either join me or vacate the premises for the concerts!!! lol :D
 
gellor

gellor

Full Audioholic
I definitely want to pick up some more iron maiden at some point.

They were my first ever concert...and I got back stage. I've still got the backstage pass signed by Steve Harris. He was a really cool guy. Sat and talked with us for about 15-20 minutes.

I'm sorry you thought this album sounded bad, though. There have been too many of those lately.
 
Rock&Roll Ninja

Rock&Roll Ninja

Audioholic Field Marshall
gellor said:
I'm sorry you thought this album sounded bad, though. There have been too many of those lately.
There really should be 3 mixes for every album:

1.The crappy download market mix. For people who probably won't pay anyway, engineered to sound good on a boombox.

2.The binaural mix, for use with headphones.

3.The good stereo mix.
 
Jack Hammer

Jack Hammer

Audioholic Field Marshall
Too bad you didn't like the mix. I've got a lot of their stuff on cd. You forgot to mention two of what I thought were the coolest trivia things about Iron Maiden:
1. They were on tour playing mostly sold-out shows (if I recall correctly) for over 11 years straight before they took a summer vacation break. Then came back and kept the momentum going.
2. They were notorious soccer fans and often played with the other bands they would tour with or the openers, and even sometimes played in the parking lots before shows. :D
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top