Help me decide between amp/bookshelves pairs

P

PearlcorderS701

Banned
I've seen that Marantz integrated suggested above in Crutchfield's catalog, and it doesn't look bad; it just doesn't seem like it pumps out all that much wattage, but that's debatable and may not be something the OP requires in great gobs (power, that is).

Marantz also makes a stereo receiver model that looks like a powerhouse, but in my own personal opinion, I am having reservations about this brand; I lost a CD changer and then a recorder, and now I am having problems with my CC4001 changer in which the thing won't read a disc in the carousel and just skips over it completely, making compilation recordings I'm doing a nightmare because of error after error...also, it's been skipping on a lot of CDs lately, and that's with cleaning the laser...

I'm not so sure about Marantz anymore -- but that's just their source decks, not their amps or receivers and such.
 
KEW

KEW

Audioholic Overlord
I totally understand this concern, and your opinion is valid -- however, there are stereo receivers that offer subwoofer outs such as my 8555 and the Outlaw, supposedly; although the concept of "bass management" is sketchy with these units...
I stated that a typical stereo receiver has a "sub out" connection. Here is the quote:
1) Will you use a subwoofer? -
While a typical stereo receiver has a subwoofer output, there is absolutely no bass management - the receiver is sending full range signal to your speakers and full range signal to your subwoofer. If you are running bookshelf speakers, it is nice if you can save them from trying to reproduce below ~80Hz.
The AVR will eliminate the low frequencies from the speakers and the high frequencies from the sub and the rate of rolloff is balanced between the two.
I am familiar with the Onkyo 8555. I would consider it a typical receiver. It sends full range signals to both the speakers and the sub.
The Outlaw does offer bass management and is the model I was thinking of as atypical when I wrote that the typical stereo receiver has no bass management. The Outlaw is a nice unit, but not inexpensive.

Stereo receivers have a second bank of speaker terminals for a "zone" outside of the main.
Not at all the same thing!
The stereo receiver's terminals are for "B" speakers. You have no separate control of the "B" speakers as you would for a 2nd zone on an AVR (which has separate volume and source controls so you can listen to two different (or the same) sources at different volumes in the two rooms).


Most AVR companies don't list or specify their products' output in all channels driven verbage, and that really wouldn't be ideal for music listening anyway in my opinion (that is, sending music through five, six or seven channels)
I was not suggesting five, six, or seven channels! Here is the quote:
4) How much power do you need? -
Because an AVR is designed to power 5 or 7 speakers simultaneously, if you use it for only 2 channels, you end up with extra dynamic headroom. Does it matter? That depends on the efficiency of your speakers and how loud you listen.
The relevance of the features is totally up to the users situation and objectives for their system.
Your Onkyo is a fine stereo receiver.
I simply listed possible reasons a person might buy an AVR for use in a stereo system so the OP could make an educated decision.
 
P

PearlcorderS701

Banned
I stated that a typical stereo receiver has a "sub out" connection. Here is the quote:
From my understanding it is atypical for a stereo receiver to offer a sub out...

Perhaps this is something just appearing in more uber-new models?

I am familiar with the Onkyo 8555. I would consider it a typical receiver. It sends full range signals to both the speakers and the sub.
The Outlaw does offer bass management and is the model I was thinking of as atypical when I wrote that the typical stereo receiver has no bass management. The Outlaw is a nice unit, but not inexpensive.
So, you're saying now that it is your stance that typically stereo receivers have no sub out? And with regard to the 8555, it was my understanding -- and how it was explained to me by Onkyo's customer support -- that there is a built-in "silent" kind of rolloff at 80Hz in the 8555, and that full range signals aren't sent to the sub, as you stated above...

Not at all the same thing!
The stereo receiver's terminals are for "B" speakers. You have no separate control of the "B" speakers as you would for a 2nd zone on an AVR (which has separate volume and source controls so you can listen to two different (or the same) sources at different volumes in the two rooms).
Okay, well, I realize they're not the same thing -- I was merely pointing out that he can have speakers running in another room (i.e. zone) with a stereo model; there isn't the amount of ultimate control like you explain many AVRs have with their Zone 2 abilities and such with the "B" terminals on stereo receivers, true, but there is the ability to run another set at least.

I was not suggesting five, six, or seven channels! Here is the quote:
Okay; again, I was merely pointing out, in a different way, that I don't believe that he needs that many channels for his application, even though you specifically state that the AVR can be run in stereo mode (something I explained to him in great detail in a previous post regarding the way I used to run all my AVRs...that is, surround receivers running in two channel, so I'm actually agreeing with you there) -- initially, I thought you were trying to suggest that these multichannel AVRs have gobs of power going to gobs of channels, and I was merely saying that they don't advertise, normally, all channels driven ratings nor do I think he needs that here. But, this was a reply to a misunderstood intention between us in terms of your quoted post here.

The relevance of the features is totally up to the users situation and objectives for their system.
Your Onkyo is a fine stereo receiver.
I simply listed possible reasons a person might buy an AVR for use in a stereo system so the OP could make an educated decision.
And that's all I was trying to say, really; my "argument" was simply that it's my humble opinion (and I apologize if it came across as anything else) that surround AVRs with onboard decoding don't make sense if the end user knows for sure that he or she won't be using it down the line for multichannel surround use. In a case like that -- strictly audio purposes -- I am suggesting to the OP that stereo applications would better suit him in my opinion, and these would include stereo receivers, integrated amplifiers or full blown separates.
 
GranteedEV

GranteedEV

Audioholic Ninja
btw, back to my recommendation(behringer active + emotiva pre), i'd like to change the USP-1 to a UMC-1. You guys are right on the money with regards to bass management.
 
KEW

KEW

Audioholic Overlord
From my understanding it is atypical for a stereo receiver to offer a sub out...

Perhaps this is something just appearing in more uber-new models?

So, you're saying now that it is your stance that typically stereo receivers have no sub out? And with regard to the 8555, it was my understanding -- and how it was explained to me by Onkyo's customer support -- that there is a built-in "silent" kind of rolloff at 80Hz in the 8555, and that full range signals aren't sent to the sub, as you stated above...
I was mistaken on the sub out being typical. I see the lesser Onkyo models do not.
When I was looking at receivers, I was looking for 80-plus watts and all of the ones I looked at did have sub outputs.

I really question the 80Hz rolloff for the subwoofer output on the TX-8555. There is absolutely no mention of that in the manual or website. Companies don't miss the chance to brag about their features. The next time I am at my brothers, I will hook up an external amp and play it through full range speakers and make certain.

The important thing that an AVR and the Outlaw offer is a high pass filter for the loudspeakers. If you are running bookshelves, it is nice not to try to make the bookshelves push their low-end limits.

Bass management does not refer to a sub out terminal, it refers to exercising control over the frequencies going to the sub and speakers.

In any case, I stand corrected on the sub output terminals.
 
K

kaungsel

Enthusiast
Thanks guys.

I have decided to go with Marantz Sr5004 just because it's more flexible and I would have an option of adding surround speakers in the future.

To play an ipod/iphone, can you guys recommend me a dock to go with the Marantz AVR?
 
3db

3db

Audioholic Slumlord
I am looking for a pair of bookshelves with an amp and it all came down to 2 choices.
I need a sound system mainly for playing music from ipod/iphone/computer
1) Marantz Sr5004 AMP $400 and Axiom M22 bookshelves $488 ($888 total)
http://www.accessories4less.com/make-a-store/item/MARSR5004/Marantz/SR5004-Dolby-TrueHD-PLIIz/dts-HD-MA-AV-Receiver/1.html
http://axiomaudio.com/m22.html
or
2) EMP E5bi package with amp/ 2 bookshelve speakers for $549 total. http://www.emptek.com/special_E5BiTubeCombo.php

Is there gonna be enough difference between these 2 to justify paying $300 more for the first one?
Does the EMP only play music or can I also hook it up to my tv?
Are you looking to move into Home Thetaer or will this strictly be a 2 channel set-up?

The reason I ask is almost all of the integrated amps/stereo receivers do NOT offer bass management. The only two that spring to mind are these:

http://outlawaudio.com/products/rr2150.html

An ugly but very capable receiver capable of driving even the most difficult speakers.

and
http://www.audioholics.com/reviews/receivers/hk-3490 which is more inline with your budget.
 
Last edited:
GranteedEV

GranteedEV

Audioholic Ninja
the sr5004 is a surround receiver with bass management

To play an ipod/iphone, can you guys recommend me a dock to go with the Marantz AVR?
Anything with digital optical-out. Before that though you may want to try out the marantz' USB-input. It can access files on PMPs and Hard Disks and play them via USB.
 
Last edited:
P

PearlcorderS701

Banned
I was mistaken on the sub out being typical. I see the lesser Onkyo models do not.
When I was looking at receivers, I was looking for 80-plus watts and all of the ones I looked at did have sub outputs.

I really question the 80Hz rolloff for the subwoofer output on the TX-8555. There is absolutely no mention of that in the manual or website. Companies don't miss the chance to brag about their features. The next time I am at my brothers, I will hook up an external amp and play it through full range speakers and make certain.

The important thing that an AVR and the Outlaw offer is a high pass filter for the loudspeakers. If you are running bookshelves, it is nice not to try to make the bookshelves push their low-end limits.

Bass management does not refer to a sub out terminal, it refers to exercising control over the frequencies going to the sub and speakers.

In any case, I stand corrected on the sub output terminals.
The 80Hz rolloff isn't mentioned anywhere in the 8555's manual -- you're correct there. I received that information directly from Onkyo's tech support. ;)
 
KEW

KEW

Audioholic Overlord
Are you looking to move into Home Thetaer or will this strictly be a 2 channel set-up?

The reason I ask is almost all of the integrated amps/stereo receivers do NOT offer bass management. The only two that spring to mind are these:

http://outlawaudio.com/products/rr2150.html

An ugly but very capable receiver capable of driving even the most difficult speakers.

and
http://www.audioholics.com/reviews/receivers/hk-3490 which is more inline with your budget.
The HK-3490 has 2 sub outputs, but it does not have bass management according to posts #15 and #16 here:
http://forums.audioholics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=66892&page=2
 
R

RMRM

Audioholic Intern
I have a pair of M22's they need a sub, sweet speaker w/a sub but in that price range sure is a lot of choices.
 
3db

3db

Audioholic Slumlord
The HK-3490 has 2 sub outputs, but it does not have bass management according to posts #15 and #16 here:
http://forums.audioholics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=66892&page=2
You maybe right KEW. I read thru the manual and there is no mention of bass managenment. I fired off an email to HK to see if there is or not. It makes no sense to have a subwoofer out unless there is some rudamentary form of bass management..ie. hard filtered at 80Hz as an example. The Outlaw unit does have bass management facilites on boad.
 
K

kaungsel

Enthusiast
the sr5004 is a surround receiver with bass management



Anything with digital optical-out. Before that though you may want to try out the marantz' USB-input. It can access files on PMPs and Hard Disks and play them via USB.
Hey Granteed,
I just got my receiver and I don't see a USB-input. Am I missing somethign here?
 
GranteedEV

GranteedEV

Audioholic Ninja
Hey Granteed,
I just got my receiver and I don't see a USB-input. Am I missing somethign here?
you have to grow your nails out.

And then dig the little front panel out where you setup audessey etc. The USB should be on the front, unless an SR5003 is different from an SR6003
 
3db

3db

Audioholic Slumlord
You maybe right KEW. I read thru the manual and there is no mention of bass managenment. I fired off an email to HK to see if there is or not. It makes no sense to have a subwoofer out unless there is some rudamentary form of bass management..ie. hard filtered at 80Hz as an example. The Outlaw unit does have bass management facilites on boad.
No response from Harmon. Great customer support you have their folks. :rolleyes:
 
K

kaungsel

Enthusiast
I ended up getting Marantz sr5004 with axiomo m22's. After setting it up, I only hear a slight difference in quality between this set up (close to $1k) and my original cheap $40 speakers. The bass is really terrible on these speakers also. :confused: Am I doing something wrong?
 
K

kaungsel

Enthusiast
What do you guys think about Polk Bookshelves? Crutchfield is having a promotion for Polk stereo systems where they include a free subwoofer ($300) with a purchase of $500 or more. Should I just return the Axioms and get this instead?
 
GranteedEV

GranteedEV

Audioholic Ninja
I ended up getting Marantz sr5004 with axiomo m22's. After setting it up, I only hear a slight difference in quality between this set up (close to $1k) and my original cheap $40 speakers. The bass is really terrible on these speakers also. :confused: Am I doing something wrong?
Terrible to what capacity? They are after all bookshelf speakers that would prefer a sub... there's a rolloff which apparently starts at 100hz or so... but that still doesn't tell us in which way the bass is terrible.

+

You aren't listening to low bitrate mp3s are you?

A few other thing i'll say are...

It may be room interaction. The axioms are not controlled directivity speakers so you may be hearing a lot of early reflections, and of course bass is always an issue.

Really, give it some time and make sure to listen to lossless music The axioms ahve a 30 day return policy so keep in touch with axiom and make sure you know how long you have to keep them. There's always and adjustment period too. You have to ask yourself what you want out of the music too... do you want a lot of extra boom? While Axioms aren't the most neutral speakers in the world, they're certainly not as "bass heavy" as some people expect.

Do read these:

http://www.audioholics.com/education/acoustics-principles/

And no, I wouldn't get the Polks.

And what wire gauge are you using? I hope you aren't using something like 24awg!
 
Last edited:
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top