Help I can’t decide...

8

8igjohn

Audiophyte
I am just stuck and can’t pull the trigger on my new receiver... I am looking at one of three and they are all so similar and I am not as familiar with them as I would like I watch 90% 10% music. I have all Polk monitor series speakers. I am really more concerned about what is going to produce the best sound.

YAMAHA RX-V867
Pioneer Elite VSX-33
Denon AVR-2311CI
Or if all I really care about is hearing great and not all the padding is the Pioneer Elite VSX-31 sufficient?
 
Pyrrho

Pyrrho

Audioholic Ninja
Among those, you should buy based on desired features. Other than engaging a circuit that affects the sound (e.g., proprietary DSP modes), they will all sound the same with any speaker that they can adequately drive.

I would say that the Pioneer Elite VSX-31 is sufficient, if it has all the features you require.

Whenever you want better sound, look to better speakers (including subwoofers) and room treatments. Except, of course, when one's amplifier is inadequate to drive one's speakers (in which case, the best option is typically to buy a separate power amplifier and use preamp outputs from the receiver, instead of buying a more expensive receiver). Otherwise, any receiver or amplifier from a reputable company will be fine.

A common mistake that people make (if sound quality is what matters to them) is to spend too much on electronics, and not enough on speakers.

In my case, I am currently running a receiver that retails for about $1700 with speakers that retail for well over $6000. Previously, I was using a receiver that retailed for $600 with the same speakers. It sounds the same as before, unless I engage a feature that affects the sound. (I bought the more expensive receiver because I wanted more features; I also got it for less than 1/3 retail price, as it was a discontinued model.) If the best sound quality is the goal, one should buy a receiver from a reputable company (e.g., Yamaha, Denon, Marantz, Pioneer) that is about as inexpensive as it can be while having all of the features one needs, and then spend one's money on the speakers (speakers, of course, include subwoofers).
 
B

boconnor811

Enthusiast
Having done similar research recently... Of those mentioned only the Denon will have actual Audessey setup to calibrate the output of your speakers while the Yamaha and Pioneer have their own proprietary solution. Recent iterations of YPAO or MCACC are improved, Audessey is generally regarded as more desirable auto-setup.
 
Pyrrho

Pyrrho

Audioholic Ninja
Having done similar research recently... Of those mentioned only the Denon will have actual Audessey setup to calibrate the output of your speakers while the Yamaha and Pioneer have their own proprietary solution. Recent iterations of YPAO or MCACC are improved, Audessey is generally regarded as more desirable auto-setup.
I have seen posts of people claiming that, but I have never seen any actual evidence that Audyssey really does a better job of balancing the speakers or setting the delays or equalizing the speakers to achieve a flat in-room response. Do you know of any tests of this in which recent versions of each of these (on comparably priced receivers) has been measured and compared?

The matter is further complicated by the fact that there are different implementations of all three, as well as other brands having their different versions of automatic setups.
 
B

boconnor811

Enthusiast
Perhaps I'm just furthering the spread of unfounded internet rumors... As being called on it, and looking back I'm not locating any definitive/direct comparison. At some point in my research this became a big issue for me (apparently unnecessarily), but given the brands the OP is looking at I don't really think there is a bad choice in the bunch.
 
8

8igjohn

Audiophyte
Thank you so much for your help!!! I will Prob go with the vsx31 I did not know that the receiver would make that little of a difference...I love the speakers I have and I spent the most I could on them...I really don't care about all the internet features and I only need 2 HDMI in and 1 out. So as far as features go I think it will be more the sufficient.
 
3db

3db

Audioholic Slumlord
Out of those three, I would go with teh one that is easiest to work with. They are all capable receviers but the on eyou find easiet to work with will be the one thats for you. I would see if you can't dwonlaod all three manuals and give them a lookover to see what seems easiet to you.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top