OK, I just took one of my surround cables, unplugged it from one amp and plugged it into the other amp, and left my front speaker hooked up to the amp, got sound just fine through the speaker. So it's definitely the preout causing the problem.
I had an Adcom amp before, tried hooking it up with terrible hum problems, kept throwing the circuit breaker, etc. Could be that's what fried my front left preout, and could have weakened the other circuit. (I used to work electronics to the component level while in the Navy, and that's not uncommon.) I've seen them work, not work, work again, etc. Those were always the hardest ones to find and fix.