For experienced audiophiles only please

lsiberian

lsiberian

Audioholic Overlord
If I may…I don’t have many posts here, but I do consider myself an audiophile. My lusting after the right sound began back in the ‘70’s, and never stopped. From a Pioneer integrated amp to a Luxman integrated to an Adcom amp & passive pre-amp, various receivers to now having a Rotel pre/pro & B&K amp, I have run the gamut. I too involved my wife early on, to justify the extra debt I was asking a newlywed couple to take in. She was receptive, but only I was able to hear the difference between speaker cables, amplification & so on.

My first pair of real speakers was Dahlquist DQ8. Very nice speaker, but the dry sound of the Adcom amp made the top end edgy. It was then that I decided to try my hand at piecing together drivers to make up a complete speaker. Changes in drivers & crossovers always lent to a different sound, but it was never right. I know I am going against the grain here, but I do believe that while changing speakers does make the most notable difference, associated equipment plays a big role also.

I found an older pair of Paradigm 5semk3 speakers on craigslist for a good price, so I picked them up. Very nice speaker, but as I like to listen to movies & TV sans a center channel speaker (phantom), they didn’t hold the image well off axis. I had tried a pair of the popular Insignia coincidental speakers from BB, and while the overall balance was not there, the imaging was rock solid over a wide area. Bearing this in mind, I began to research Kef speakers. I had always read good things about them, but it seemed the current line of bookshelf speakers got too muddy when asked to go loud. I read about the 1 generation old IQ7, considered a 2 ½ way small tower with a driver going up to 250hz before handing off the rest of the spectrum to the mid/tweeter array. I gave a listen to the only place near me that had them on display, and liked what I heard. I found a new pair at oncall.com for under $600 with free shipping. So, I pulled the trigger.

I had some trepidation about two “metal” drivers conveying the mids & highs, but after a week long break in, those worries were allayed. The imaging, which was a crucial point for me is very solid all the way across. What I wasn’t expecting though was what I encountered after an extended listening – neutrality. Of all the speakers I have listened to, these speakers, along with being bi-wired to my system, added nothing to the sound, nor took anything away. This coupled with a wide, deep soundstage made me realize I had made the right choice. (this while only being 13” from the rear wall) Conventional “tweeter over woofer” designs tend to (as one reviewer put it) suffer from the sound being “sucked out” at a mid frequency, typically at the crossover point. Not so with the Kef’s.

I am very pleased with my purchase, in case you hadn’t noticed. On you budget, the IQ6C would make a great center speaker to go along with the IQ7. But, as others here have correctly said, we can only suggest – ultimately it’s up to you what you like best. Good luck in your quest, I hoped I helped rather than hindered.
Congrats. And if you need small surrounds KEF makes the best small speakers on the market IMO. I don't see the need to bi-wire them unless your amp is just very weak or you are using very small gauge wire. I use 4 of their eggs for my surrounds. Very nice sound for the size.

the iQ6 is a very amazing center IMO. Their aren't very many centers at it's level IMO in the sub 1000 range.
 
olddog

olddog

Audioholic
OK we got to San Antonio to check out some of the local pawnshops but really did not do much of anything, as we were having to good of a time relaxing and enjoying the sights, and great food. Guys if you ever want to take that Sig. Other somewhere to show her how romantic you’re other side can be this is the place! Left here and went to Party Town (Austin) where we found some Thiel 1.6s. I never had heard Thiels before and was looking forward to this. At the same time ran across some Spenders S5e speakers? I had never even heard of them before.
The Thiels looked to be easy to drive (I thought it would be otherwise) The Tweeter was rather low, as these are not that tall of a speaker? The design is a lot different than anything we have looked at as they are slanted back to accommodate the time and phase coherency of the speakers. Kinda of an odd looking bird with a long slit on the front bottom. As to the tweeter, a tall person would probably want to put these on some sort of pedestal?
Specs
Bandwidth (-3 dB): 48 Hz-20 kHz; Amplitude Response: 50 Hz-20 kHz +/-2 dB; Phase Response: Minimum �10 degrees; Sensitivity: 90 dB@2.8 V-1m; Impedance: 4 ohms (3.0 ohms minimum); Recommended Power: 50-300 watts; Cabinet Dimensions: 9 inches wide x 11.5 inches deep x 35.5 inches high; Weight: 38 pounds
They had excellent wide sound field and resolution of details with accurate imaging. Depth was very good also. It seems though that when the Misses ran up the volume they tended to get an uncomfortable brightness? To them. They also really need about 3ft. breathing room, which I don’t have. We drove them with a Denon 3809 on pure direct stereo.

The Spender S5e
These speakers are on the smallish side for a floor stander. The components seemed to be first rate. A Seas 1” fabric dome tweeter, and two individual 140mm Spendor drive units. One driver handles the midrange and upper bass. The second bass unit handles the very low frequencies and it is engineered to match the rear flow port.
These are an easy listening speaker with good sound field and imaging. They sounded to us a little laid back on the high end and somewhat lacking on the low freq., but overall very accurate and didn’t mind being driven hard at all. The rear firing bass port once again forces placement problems for us.
We were under whelmed. Needles to say we both are getting a little tired and really want to get back home—but empty-handed?! Also this is the reason for the brevity of the review, we listened to others to but they all fell short for one reason or another, weather it was the sound design of placement or price.

Overall choice comparison so far would be:

For sound alone Vandersteen Sig 3A. Bad No adequate room for them and ugly.

Sound looks and usability Salk Sound Tower. Bad Over my budget and can’t find one used to fit my pocket book.

Price and sound: B&W 683. Bad Just a little too laid back and kinda cheap looking. (I do not have a dark AV theater) Living room for ALL TO SEE WAF.

So along with everything else we still have not found that SWEET DEAL but have a lead for this afternoon that maybe a good one!
 
C

cfrizz

Senior Audioholic
I'm glad you and your wife are enjoying your speaker shopping adventure.:)

It sounds like no matter what speaker you eventually get, a nice beefy 2 channel separate amplifier is in your future. What you are realizing is that receivers just can't cut it when the pedal is pressed to the metal!

You will most likely need at least a 200wpc amp, which is what I always recommend to get the best out of any speaker.

I think it's totally cool that your wife is so into this right with you!:cool:

I'm looking forward to your next review.
 
olddog

olddog

Audioholic
I'm glad you and your wife are enjoying your speaker shopping adventure.:)

It sounds like no matter what speaker you eventually get, a nice beefy 2 channel separate amplifier is in your future. What you are realizing is that receivers just can't cut it when the pedal is pressed to the metal!

You will most likely need at least a 200wpc amp, which is what I always recommend to get the best out of any speaker.

I think it's totally cool that your wife is so into this right with you!:cool:

I'm looking forward to your next review.
Your abosutley correct! Bottle's I would think. Any suggestions? Not too crazy please.
 
olddog

olddog

Audioholic
I found our speakers here in Austin wow!!! Were going home with them now. Man are they heavy! Took two of us to carry them and three to load them but they defiantly have the WAF all the way. B Day was on the 18th so I almost made it, better late than not:):D
 
lsiberian

lsiberian

Audioholic Overlord
I found our speakers here in Austin wow!!! Were going home with them now. Man are they heavy! Took two of us to carry them and three to load them but they defiantly have the WAF all the way. B Day was on the 18th so I almost made it, better late than not:):D
Hey make sure you check out Chuy's, SaltLick, Rudy's and Lone Star Bakery in Round Rock. What did you get? Also in Round Rock there is a very good cajun restaurant on main street.

Ok talking about my hometown makes me hungry for home cooking.
 
C

cfrizz

Senior Audioholic
Congrats on finding your speakers, can't wait to hear what they are & how they sound.

As for amplification, Emotiva XPA-2 is good bang for the buck. Other companies to look at that make good amps are Parasound, Rotel, B & K, Nad, Sunfire, Adcom.

If you don't mind buying used Audiogon will get you a lot for your money.

Your abosutley correct! Bottle's I would think. Any suggestions? Not too crazy please.
 
olddog

olddog

Audioholic
Folks I know I have sinned:eek: so please forgive me. Here’s the rest of the story.


Well we got to Austin and checked into my friends house, rested a few then went out and checked out the Thiel 1.6 then the Spender S5e as in my previous post. Then we bought some steaks and went back to my buds home to have a little cook up. He was out with his son watching him play baseball.
Later, when they had gotten home and we had all eaten Susan and I were telling them about our travels. His son up and tells us about one of his baseball buds dad that was doing a big remodel on their home, and had a couple of speakers for sale as they were doing an AV in-wall install. I asked if he had a phone# and I called. When we got over there I ended up meeting a true brother in arms. He was in the midst of a very big re-model for sure. He had taken out the fireplace and replaced it with an electric one. Where the chimney had been was now a recess across the wall that he had installed a large DLP and on either side 2x5ft holes cut out that would be receiving his new in wall speakers, along with ceiling holes cut in with boxes to suspend his new surrounds for a 7/1. He also had a custom recess off to the side to take in his equipment, one of which was a pair of Cary 805Cs:cool: and a wireless music on demand (I gotta get one). He had his old speakers, turntable and amp (not the Cary’s) for sale he said, as he would not be needing them any longer.


I have been cautioned and have learned that first impressions are dangerous. It's why speaker retailers are considered a want-a-be or used-to-be car salesman, because they know how to exploit the one-hour demo. It's only later, after you've lived with your purchase, that you find out it's a great source for listener fatigue, and you'd been seduced by its special attributes rather than by accuracy or naturalness or musicality. If anything, I think you would want to err on the side of politeness, in sharp contrast to spitty, edgy, nasty aggression (Gee, who does that remind me of?)(Not me I’m sure).! So we cranked them up with his Cary’s and spent some time shooting pool on a Beautifull Manhattan, Brunswick he had just acquired. He put on some Frank and Dino and Aretha, Peggy, Ray Charles and Ella and the voices were so realistic that Susan and I agreed it felt like you could just reach out and touch them. I also pulled out my reference CD’s that have some particular high freq. cuts that have given many so far a problem (Brian Setzer Live in Japan) I couldn't get them to spit or sizzle, and yet never did I feel that the top end was lacking. Now these speakers have metal tweeters and what veteran metal tweeter haters will find so disconcerting is that we found them smooth, sweet and velvety - almost a complete denial of metal tweeter values. But I suspect that part of the effect was the speaker's room-filling dispersion. With no head-clamped-in-a-vice hot-seat effect, there was a seamless, wall-to-wall sonic stage, with a texture and depth, which can only be described as 'silky smooth', and warm and caressing with no upper-frequency nastiness. Yes a little colored but in a good way that leaves everything clean and accurate. More than once, I heard an instrument play way off axis and the bass while not strong or thumping was, or just, felt “just right”. Susan and I, both of our own separate accord came to the conclusion that these were just right. They did not interpret but were merely a conduit for the music in a most pleasing and realistic way. I had heard that you have to be careful with the front-end equipment with these speakers and that worried me no little bit, as all I have is a Denon 2808, but my new friend said that it should not be a problem and it has proven with proper placement and sub settings he was right.
We came to the point of an offer, and when he spoke first I took it. No Haggle. I was tired:rolleyes:
1200.00 inc. a 10ft. pair of Audioquest DBS BI-Wire and a pair of lead shot and sand filled stands from the Mfg.(the speakers were attached with a special adhesive and bolted to these stands and he said he was not taking them off, so they weighed about 100lbs. Each)



Specifications:

Description: 2-way vented-box system
Drive units: 1x 1-inch aluminum dome high-frequency, 1x 6.5-inch woven Kevlar cone bass / midrange
Frequency range: -6dB at 42Hz and 50kHz
Frequency response: 49Hz - 22kHz ±3dB on reference axis
Dispersion: within 2dB of reference response
Horizontal: over 60º arc
Vertical: over 10º arc
Sensitivity: 88dB spl (2.83V, 1m)
Harmonic Distortion: 2nd and 3rd harmonics – 90dB, 1m, <1% 100Hz - 22kHz, <0.5% 150Hz - 20kHz
Nominal Impedance: 8Ω (minimum 3.7Ω)
Crossover frequencies: 4kHz
Recommended Power: 50W - 120W into 8Ω on unclipped program
Max. Recommended Cable Impedance: 0.1Ω
Dimensions: 16.5 H x 9.4 W x 13.8 D (inch)
Weight: 26lb

Now if you haven’t guessed yet—the envelope please?
Please guys don’t hate me, pillage my village and or take my women, the price was just too good to pass up—and did I hear, or listen to better speakers-YES, but not at this PRICE!

B&W 805S:eek:
1200.00 with B&W stands (already filled) and Audioquest speaker cable. Now I have an extra 1200.00 for a tube amp.:D
They are in pristine condition, and the natural grain finish is just beautifull. After some tweaking for placement they are all of the above. I know some have said they found this speaker to be too harsh or bright? I really thought I had screwed the pooch when I first got these home as they sounded just that way setting 9” from the back wall. First I blamed the amp, and then went into depression, denial and pre-separation:(. Then I decided to really get into tweaking them out. I moved them out from the wall about 4 ft. where they immediately lost the harshness. Then carefully moved them back till it started again (at 100lbs. each no small task). They ended up at 18 & 3/8 in. from back wall. Then I went into the amp and set them to small and set the sub crossover to 80Hz, along with that I boosted the 4Hz freq to 4.5DB. Then I set the pair of subs to 80HZ and backed off the attack till the transition from speaker to sub was unnoticeable. Susan has cranked them to 120Db (RS meter) and they still are rock solid and except for the VolumeJ no fatigue. This is all for music only, where I used an unused (7/1) amp channel and assigned it this task. I kept my HT (5/1) in tact so I have actually come a full circle, back to where I started looking in the beginning.
I have been listening to them as I wrote this. Thank you all for your help and guidance in my hunt and if I can be of any help to you just let me know please.

Old Texas Dog
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top